- Research article
- Open Access
Genome-wide analysis of autophagy-associated genes in foxtail millet (Setaria italica L.) and characterization of the function of SiATG8a in conferring tolerance to nitrogen starvation in rice
- Weiwei Li†1View ORCID ID profile,
- Ming Chen†2,
- Erhui Wang3,
- Liqin Hu2,
- Malcolm J. Hawkesford4,
- Li Zhong2,
- Zhu Chen5,
- Zhaoshi Xu2,
- Liancheng Li2,
- Yongbin Zhou2,
- Changhong Guo1Email author and
- Youzhi Ma2Email author
© The Author(s). 2016
- Received: 9 January 2016
- Accepted: 23 September 2016
- Published: 12 October 2016
Autophagy is a cellular degradation process that is highly evolutionarily-conserved in yeast, plants, and animals. In plants, autophagy plays important roles in regulating intracellular degradation and recycling of amino acids in response to nutrient starvation, senescence, and other environmental stresses. Foxtail millet (Setaria italica) has strong resistance to stresses and has been proposed as an ideal material for use in the study of the physiological mechanisms of abiotic stress tolerance in plants. Although the genome sequence of foxtail millet (Setaria italica) is available, the characteristics and functions of abiotic stress-related genes remain largely unknown for this species.
A total of 37 putative ATG (autophagy-associated genes) genes in the foxtail millet genome were identified. Gene duplication analysis revealed that both segmental and tandem duplication events have played significant roles in the expansion of the ATG gene family in foxtail millet. Comparative synteny mapping between the genomes of foxtail millet and rice suggested that the ATG genes in both species have common ancestors, as their ATG genes were primarily located in similar syntenic regions. Gene expression analysis revealed the induced expression of 31 SiATG genes by one or more phytohormone treatments, 26 SiATG genes by drought, salt and cold, 24 SiATG genes by darkness and 25 SiATG genes by nitrogen starvation. Results of qRT-PCR showing that among 37 SiATG genes, the expression level of SiATG8a was the highest after nitrogen starvation treatment 24 h, suggesting its potential role in tolerance to nutrient starvation. Moreover, the heterologous expression of SiATG8a in rice improved nitrogen starvation tolerance. Compared to wild type rice, the transgenic rice performed better and had higher aboveground total nitrogen content when the plants were grown under nitrogen starvation conditions.
Our results deepen understanding about the characteristics and functions of ATG genes in foxtail millet and also identify promising new genetic resources that should be of use in future efforts to develop varieties of foxtail millet and other crop species that have resistance to nitrogen deficiency stress.
- Foxtail millet
- Autophagy-associated genes
- Expression pattern
- Functional identification
- Nitrogen starvation
The yield and quality of crops are adversely influenced under adverse environmental conditions, such as high salt, drought, and nutrient starvation. In order to survive, plants have evolved various capacities that enable them to resist or adapt to environmental changes. Autophagy is a highly evolutionarily-conserved cellular degradation process that is induced by nutrient starvation and it is essential for recycling of the cellular cytoplasmic contents and the breakdown of damaged proteins [1, 2]. In autophagy, the macromolecules or organelles are sequestered into a double-membraned vesicle termed an autophagosome. The content of autophagosome ranges from damaged proteins to obsolete organelles. This content is finally delivered into a vacuole (in yeast and plants) or a lysosome (animals) for degradation and nutrient recycling during periods of stress and starvation [1, 2]. Autophagy maintains cellular homeostasis during stressful conditions and plays important roles in various cellular processes. Therefore, the molecular and physiological mechanisms of plant autophagy are attracting more and more research attention.
Identification of genes that participate in autophagy should establish a foundation for furthering our understanding of the molecular mechanism and the potential roles of autophagy in different physiological processes. So far, most of our knowledge about autophagy comes from studies of yeast. In yeast, the number of ATG genes currently stands at 41 [3–7]. A group of autophagy-defective mutants have been isolated and used to study the autophagy process in yeast [8–12]. The studies of these yeast mutants have revealed the molecular mechanisms underlying autophagy . The plant and mammalian homologues of the yeast ATG genes have been found, and these show conservation of the core ATG mechanism during evolution. Recently, some ATG homologues have been found and functionally analyzed in the genomes of Arabidopsis, rice, and maize [14–17]. Through genome sequencing, a total of 33 ATG homologues are known to exist in the rice (Oryza sativa) genome, and more than 30 ATG genes have been identified in Arabidopsis thaliana, tobacco, maize [16–19]. Autophagy is involved in a variety of processes in plant metabolism and development, including apoptotic processes, senescence, nutrient starvation, vacuole biogenesis, and seed development. Autophagy is related to responses to biotic and abiotic stresses such as viral infection and oxidative, salt, and drought stress [1, 20–22]. Under normal conditions, autophagy is kept at a low level, but it can be activated by nutrient starvation, which is known to induce the expression of some ATG genes . The rice mutant Osatg7-1 has reduced biomass production and nitrogen use efficiency compared with wild type plants . Under nitrogen starvation, the maize atg12 mutant shows enhanced leaf senescence and stunted ear development. Nitrogen partitioning studies revealed that seed yield and the nitrogen-harvest index were significantly decreased in the atg12 mutant . Some Arabidopsis autophagy-defective mutants are also known to be particularly sensitive to nutrient starvation. Transgenic Arabidopsis plants of an ATG-knockdown line, RNAi-ATG18a, have been shown to be more sensitive than wild type plants to nutrient-limiting conditions . The Arabidopsis atg mutants, such as atg4a4b-1, atg5-1, atg7-1, atg9-1 and atg10-1 exhibited abnormal phenotypes (chlorosis, decreased bolting time, and early senescence) under nutrient starvation [21, 22, 25–29]. ATG8, one of the conserved autophagy proteins, is a lipid-conjugated ubiquitin-like protein that functions as a scaffold for membrane expansion during autophagosome formation [30, 31]. In contrast to the single ATG8 gene present in the genome of budding yeast, there are nine and six ATG8 orthologues present in the Arabidopsis and rice genomes, respectively [16, 32]. In plant cells, AtAtg8 synthetic substrates can be efficiently incorporated into autophagosomes, and this processing is known to require AtAtg4s. Synthetic AtAtg8 substrate could be processed efficiently in an AtAtg4-dependent manner. These results indicate that, in vivo, the synthetic AtAtg8 substrate is used efficiently in the biogenesis of autophagosomes . Under nitrogen starvation, the expression and transcription patterns of OsATG8 homologues were different in various tissues, indicating that the functions among homologues maybe different . In plants, ATG8 genes are known to function efficiently in cellular processes in young, non-senescing tissues, under both favorable growth conditions and under starvation stress . TdATG8, from wild emmer wheat, may play a role in a drought tolerance mechanism and TdATG8 is known to be a positive regulator of osmotic and drought stress responses . Expression of AtATG8 in Arabidopsis increased plant sensitivity to mild salt and osmotic stress . Heterologous expression of GmATG8c in Arabidopsis conferred tolerance to nitrogen deficiency and increased yields . To date, plant autophagy research has been concentrated on model plant species, few studies have explored the functions of ATG-like genes in non-model crop species.
Foxtail millet (Setaria italica L.) is a member of the Poaceae grass family and is an ancient crop in China. Foxtail millet is an important food and fodder crop in arid regions because of its characteristics such as resistance to drought and nutrition deficiency stress. Published plant genome sequences have facilitated research on foxtail millet [38–40]. However, there have been few articles reporting studies related to stress-related gene function in foxtail millet so far. In this study, 37 ATG genes in the foxtail millet genome (internally annotated as Setaria italica autophagy- associated genes; SiATGs) were identified. We determined their chromosomal locations, predicted the protein structures and analyzed the expression patterns of these 37 SiATG genes with qRT-PCR. The results showed that among SiATG genes the expression level of SiATG8a was the highest after low nitrogen treatment 24 h and overexpression of SiATG8a enhanced the tolerance of transgenic rice to nitrogen starvation stress. Our results deepen understanding about the characteristics and functions of ATG genes in foxtail millet and also identify promising new genetic resources for foxtail millet and other crop species that have resistance to nitrogen deficiency stress.
Bioinformatics analysis of 37 SiATG genes: identification and chromosomal distribution
A total of 37 putative ATG genes were identified in foxtail millet via genome-wide analysis (Additional file 1: Table S1). Their domains were further confirmed with the Pfam database (http://pfam.xfam.org/). The lengths of the amino acid sequences, the predicted molecular weights, and the predicted isoelectric points (pI) (Additional file 1: Table S1 and S2) differed greatly among the 37 SiATG proteins. The coding sequences, genomic sequences, protein sequences and nucleotide sequences upstream of the initiation codon for transcription for the 37 SiATGs were all downloaded from (www.phytozome.net/). The deduced SiATG protein sequences ranged from 91 amino acids (SiATG12) to 2474 amino acids (SiTOR), and the corresponding molecular weights varied from 10 to 278 kDa. The predicted isoelectric points varied from 4.53 (SiATG3a) to 9.51 (SiATI12a). According to information on the phytozome website, ten proteins were found to be splice variants of primary transcripts encoding autophagy-associated proteins: SiATG1, SiATG5, SiATG8b, SiATG8d, SiATG10, SiATG16, SiTOR, SiVPS15, SiVPS34, and SiNBR1 (Additional file 1: Table S1).
Phylogenetic analysis of foxtail millet ATGs with ATGs of other plant species, and gene structure analysis
As with other plants, some foxtail millet ATG members are encoded by small gene families, implying redundancy and subfunctionalization (ATG8, ATG13, ATG18). Other foxtail millet ATG members are encoded by a single gene (ATG1, ATG2, ATG4, ATG5, ATG10, ATG11, ATG12, ATG16,ATG27, TOR, VPS15, VPS34,and NBR1), making them attractive research materials for reverse genetics studies .
Duplication and divergence rates of the SiATG genes
Ka/Ks analysis and estimation of the absolute dates for the duplication events between the duplicated SiATG homologues
Date (million years)
Among the orthologous gene pairs of SiATG with other grass species, the highest average Ka/Ks value was between sorghum and foxtail millet (0.2061) and the lowest average Ka/Ks value were between maize and foxtail millet (0.1826). The rate of Ks of ATG genes between rice and foxtail millet was relatively higher than between sorghum and maize, with the divergence between foxtail millet and rice probably occurring between 36-95 MYA (Additional file 1: Tables S4–S6). Conversely, the Ka/Ks ratio of the ATG gene pairs between foxtail millet and maize (Ka/Ks = 0.1826) was lower than that of sorghum and foxtail millet (average Ka/Ks = 0.2061) and that of foxtail millet and rice (Ka/Ks = 0.1834). These results suggest that intense purifying selection between foxtail millet and maize was more significant than that of sorghum and foxtail millet, and foxtail millet and that of rice. The divergence time between foxtail millet and maize was at the latest17–82 MYA.
Differential expression profiles of the foxtail millet ATG genes under phytohormone, abiotic stress, and nitrogen and carbon starvation treatments
To investigate the effect of different abiotic stresses treatments on the expression the foxtail millet ATG genes, we used qRT-PCR to monitor the expression patterns of the 37ATG genes in plants grown under drought, salt, and cold treatment (both 1 h and 24 h duration treatments). As shown in Fig. 6, the expression of most of the SiATG genes was either induced or suppressed as a result of these abiotic stress treatments. Although it was the case that the expression of most SiATG homologues was altered during the early stages of drought treatment, the expression of all 37 SiATG genes had clearly increased during the later stages of treatment. The expression of most of the SiATG genes was down-regulated during the early cold stress treatment, although the expression of seven genes was increased slightly (e.g.,SiATG10, SiATG16, and SiATG27).
To study the expression patterns of the 37 SiATG genes in response to carbon starvation stress, foxtail millet plants were kept in darkness for 48 h. As shown in Fig. 7a, seven SiATG genes (SiATG6a, SiATG7a, SiATG8a, SiATG8b, SiATG8c, SiATG9a and SiATG9b) showed highly expressed in darkness. The expression of the other SiATG genes was not changed significantly under this treatment. To monitor the response of SiATG genes in foxtail millet during nitrogen starvation, the expression of the 37 SiATG genes was analyzed in plants that had been subjected to nitrogen-free treatment for 1 h and for 24 h (Fig. 7b). After 1 h of treatment, the expression of most of the 37 SiATG genes was up-regulated, although the expression of SiATG27 was down-regulated. After 24 h of starvation, the expression of many genes was elevated. Among 37 SiATG genes the expression level of SiATG8a was the highest after low nitrogen treatment 24 h, suggesting its potential role in tolerance to nutrient starvation.
Overexpression of SiATG8a in rice conferred improved tolerance to nitrogen starvation
Heterologous expression of SiATG8a in rice enhances tolerance to nitrogen starvation
The Arabidopsis autophagy mutants, such as atg4a4b-1, atg5-1, atg7-1, atg9-1, atg10-1 and ATG18aRNAi plants exhibited abnormal phenotypes compared to the wild-type plant (chlorosis, decreased bolting time, and early senescence) under nutrient starvation, which confirmed the important roles of autophagy in nutrient recycling [21, 22, 25–29]. Constitutive expression of GmATG8c in soybean callus cells enhanced nitrogen starvation tolerance and accelerated the growth of the calli. Transgenic Arabidopsis over-expressing GmATG8c increased the yield under the nitrogen starvation compared to wild type plants . In our study, expression level of SiATG8a was the highest among 37 SiATG genes under nitrogen starvation condition, indicating its potential role in nutrient starvation responses. The SiATG8a transgenic plants appeared to be more robust than the wild type, indicating SiATG8a conferred transgenic plants tolerance to low nitrogen supply. N utilization is a complex process that consists of several steps, including uptake, translocation, assimilation, and remobilization . Many results indicate that nutrient recycling could be precisely controlled by altering the timing and strength of autophagic processes, which would offer novel strategies for the improvement of N utilization in other crops [17, 24, 44]. Leaf soluble proteins can be rapidly degraded and are a major source of N in plants. Autophagy has recently been reported to be implicated in efficient nitrogen remobilization in senescent leaves, it facilitates protein degradation for nitrogen recycling in these organs [24, 45]. Tolerance to low nitrogen of SiATG8a might be related to the presumed enhanced protein degradation and utilization ability in senescent leaves. We found that the total nitrogen content of the aboveground parts in transgenic plants is significantly higher than that in control plants under low nitrogen condition (Fig. 8d). We also measured the total nitrogen content of roots and found that the total root nitrogen content in the three transgenic rice lines was slightly reduced compared to the wild type rice, but the difference was not statistically significant (Fig. 8e). There were no significant differences in the total nitrogen content for whole plants between transgenic and control plants (Additional file 1: Figure S5). These results indicated that the translocation of nitrogen from roots to aboveground organs might be enhanced in transgenic plants, which lead to strong tolerance to low nitrogen stress of transgenic plants. Further study will be necessary to characterize the molecular basis of how the SiATG8a promote influences nitrogen translocation from roots to aboveground organs in plants.
The analysis of genes structure, phylogenetic classification, duplication and divergence rates of the SiATG genes
Many genes are known to be involved in autophagy. In yeast, 41 ATGs genes have been identified and confirmed to function in autophagy. In recent years, the autophagy-associated genes in multiple plant species have been identified. More than 30 ATG genes have been identified in Arabidopsis thaliana, Zea mays, Oryza sativa and Nicotiana tabacum genomes, demonstrating the evolutionarily conservation of the core ATG mechanism in different species [16–19]. A comprehensive search for autophagy- associated gene superfamily members from the PHYTOZOME database has revealed the presence of 37 SiATG genes, which is similar to the number of such genes in rice, tobacco and maize [16, 17, 19]. Unlike yeast where there is only a single copy, multiple copies of autophagy genes such as ATG8, exist in other species. For example, there are five, nine and eleven copies of ATG8 in tobacco, Arabidopsis, and soybean, respectively [16, 19, 32]. The unrooted phylogenetic trees suggested that each SiATG protein sequence was highly similar to their homologues in other plant species, it clearly shows the derivation of statistically reliable pairs of possible orthologues proteins sharing similar functions from a common ancestor. These results are consistent with the present understanding of plant evolutionary history . Close association of SiATG families with their counter-parts in other plants, expressions or functions for most of which have reported, may be an implication of sequence conservation and evidence to their similar biological roles. Such phylogeny-based function prediction has been applied for prediction of stress-responsive proteins in other species like rice, Arabidopsis and maize. Although SiATG proteins tended to cluster together in the tree with respect to their type and they were not equally distributed in the clades which may be due to the occurrence of duplication and divergence of SiATG genes.
In this study, the exon-intron structures of ATG genes identified in the foxtail millet indicated that the exon-intron structures were conserved in foxtail millet. The results of inter-genomic analyses between rice, sorghum, maize, and foxtail millet revealed that there is highly conserved colinearity, which supports a close evolutionary relationship among these grasses . To further explore the origin and evolutionary process of SiATG genes, a comparative synteny map between foxtail millet and rice genomes was produced which showed that there are 22 genes unambiguously existing in both the foxtail millet and rice genomes. These results suggest that the majority of SiATG genes share a common ancestor with OsATG genes counterparts. Despite the close evolutionary relationship between the foxtail millet and rice, the chromosomes of grasses have undergone extensive rearrangement. There are some SiATG genes that were not mapped onto any colinear blocks with rice, such as SiATG8a. A possible explanation for this is that foxtail millet and rice chromosomes have undergone extensive rearrangements and fusions that led to selective gene loss, which makes the identification of chromosomal syntenies difficult . It does not mean that these ATG genes from foxtail millet and rice do not share a common ancestor but may be linked to environmental conditions in which some millet genes might be more appropriate and result in a better performance than rice. Gene duplication events play a key role in the expansion of gene families . Many genes are known to be involved in autophagy most of the foxtail millet duplications were generated in the whole genome duplication (WGD) event similar to that in Brachypodium, rice, sorghum and maize, this was estimated to have occurred approximately 70 MYA . In this study, gene duplication analysis revealed that segmental and tandem duplicated events resulted in the generation of multiple copies of SiATG genes, suggesting that these events play a significant role in the expansion of the SiATG gene family. In addition, some duplicate genes are important in the evolution of new traits and in speciation . In the long-term evolution process, some genes may have a relatively more important role. In genetics, the calculation of the Ka/Ks ratio is an important parameter when deciding whether Darwinian positive selection was involved in gene divergence . In all organisms, the majority of non-synonymous substitutions are harmful mutation; only a minority neutral or favorable mutations. Darwinian positive selection will retain the benefit of the non-synonymous mutations, whereas, for the harmful non-synonymous mutations, purifying selection will remove them gradually. In the present study, the average ratio of Ka/Ks for segmentally duplicated gene pairs is 0.210, whereas the Ka/Ks value for tandemly duplicated gene pairs was 0.34, strongly indicating that the SiATG gene family underwent a strong purifying selection pressure as the Ka/Ks ratios of six duplicated pairs were <1. Comparative genomic analysis is a quick way to extrapolate genomic knowledge acquired in one taxon to a less-well-studied species . Duplicate genes tend to diverge in coding and regulatory regions. Divergences in coding regions can change the function of the gene or may lead to the acquisition of new functions as a result of amino acid-altering substitutions and/or alterations in exon-intron structure, divergence in regulatory regions can result in change in expression pattern . Previous research has revealed that the foxtail millet genome underwent whole-genome duplication similar to other grasses about 70 MYA . The relatively higher rate of synonymous substitution between rice and foxtail millet ATG genes may point towards their earlier divergence around 36–95 MYA as compared to sorghum and maize ATG genes.
Expression of SiATG genes in response to stress treatments
Under adverse environmental conditions, plants adopt various strategies to respond to particular stresses to enable growth and survival . Many studies have shown that ATG proteins play key roles in plant responses to various environmental stresses [1, 20–22]. Cell autophagy generally remains at a low level in unstressed plants but can be induced when plants are subjected to adverse external stress. During such stress, plants require several phytohormone, including ABA, GA, MeJA and SA, which play key regulatory roles in different plant processes . In our study, expression profile analysis demonstrated that all 37 SiATGs genes displayed variations in their expression behavior in response to one or more stresses, as shown in Additional file 1: Table S8. The complex expression patterns in response to one or more hormones implied that these 37 SiATGs may play different roles in response to multiple environmental stimuli. Oxidative, high salt and osmotic stress conditions can induce autophagy in plants. High salinity causes ion stress and drought usually leads to osmotic stress in the plant . The accumulation of ROS (reactive oxygen species) and oxidized proteins in plant cells increased in plants grown under drought and salt stress conditions . Autophagy is a macromolecular degradation pathway through which oxidized proteins can be voided. Transgenic RNAi-AtATG18a plants are more sensitive to ROS, salt and drought conditions than are wild type plants . AtATG8 and OsATG10b have been reported to play important roles in responses to salt and osmotic stresses [36, 55]. Recent studies have shown that autophagy plays an important role in nitrogen remobilization and seed production in Arabidopsis [44, 45]. During leaf senescence, nitrogen and fixed-carbon limitations, the levels of maize ATG transcripts and/ or the ATG8-lipid adduct were increased indicating that autophagy plays important role in nutrient remobilization . In this study, most of the 37 SiATGs responded differentially to at least one stress (Fig. 6). SiATG6a, SiATG8a, SiATG8c and SiATG9a showed increased expression during carbohydrate starvation and SiATG8a, SiATG8c and SiATG9a were up-regulated under nitrogen starvation (Fig. 7a, b). Those results indicated that ATG genes are widely involved in various abiotic stress responses of plants in addition to low nitrogen stress in plants.
A total of 37 putative SiATG genes were identified in foxtail millet through genome-wide analysis. We analyzed the chromosomal distribution, intron-exon structures, duplication and divergence rates, differential expression profiles under phytohormone, abiotic stresses, and nitrogen and carbon starvation treatments. Heterologous expression of SiATG8a in rice enhanced tolerance to nitrogen starvation in this study.
Plant materials and growth conditions
Seeds of foxtail millet were soaked in water and germinated at 28 °C for 2 days and then grown in Hoagland solution for 3 weeks. For the stress treatments, 3-week-old seedlings were exposed to high salt (100mM NaCl), drought (6 % PEG 6000), or hormones (5μM abscisic acid (ABA), 5μM salicylic acid (SA), 5μM methyl jasmonate (MeJA), and 5μM gibberellic acid (GA)) for 1 h and 24 h, respectively [56–58]. The carbon starvation and cold treatments were achieved, respectively, by keeping the seedlings in the dark for 48 h and keeping the seedlings at 4 °C for 1 h and 24 h. For the nitrogen-free treatment, foxtail millet seeds were surface sterilized and then germinated on MS medium (0.8 %w/v agar, 3 %sucrose) and cultured under a 16/8 h light/ dark photoperiod for 14 days. On day 15, seedlings were cultured on nitrogen-deficient liquid medium (modified MS medium with 5 mM KCl, 3 mM CaCl2, 1.5 mM MgSO4, 1.25mM KH2PO4, pH 5.8) for 1 h and 24 h. Control seedlings were grown in normal MS medium. For the nitrogen starvation treatment, 40 millet varieties were randomly chosen, the relative reduction values for the three replicates are presented. The list of the foxtail millet varieties examined in this study is shown in Additional file 1: Table S7. At the end of the treatments, all of the samples were frozen immediately in liquid nitrogen and stored at -80 °C prior to analysis.
Bioinformatics analysis of the autophagy gene family in foxtail millet
Some ATG-like genes (SiATGs) were identified in the foxtail millet genomic database (PHYTOZOME v9.0 database, www.phytozome.net/) using ‘autophagy’ as a key word. Other foxtail millet ATGs, together with ATG proteins from yeast, rice, Arabidopsis, tobacco, and maize (sources detailed subsequently), were identified in the PHYTOZOME v9.0 database via BLASP using the ATG domain as a query. The coding sequences, genomic sequences, protein sequences and nucleotide sequences upstream of the initiation codon for transcription for the 37 SiATGs were all downloaded from (www.phytozome.net/). Yeast ATG protein sequences were downloaded from Pfam26.0 (http://pfam.sanger.ac.uk/) [3–7]. The Arabidopsis ATG protein sequences were downloaded from the Arabidopsis information resource (https://www.arabidopsis.org/). The NtATG, ZmATG, and OsATG protein sequences were downloaded from (www.phytozome.net/) [16–19]. All redundant sequences were removed using the ‘decrease redundancy’ tool at http://web.expasy.org/decrease_redundancy/. Each putative SiATG gene sequence was checked by SMART (http://smart.embl-heidelberg.de/) to confirm the presence of the ATG domain. For nomenclature, the prefix `Si` for Setaria italica was used, followed by ‘ATG’. The serial number for each foxtail millet autophagy-associated genes member was assigned according to their relationship with the members of rice, Arabidopsis, tobacco, and maize autophagy-associated genes family. The subcellular localizations of the SiATG proteins were predicted using YLoc (http://abi.inf.uni-tuebingen.de/Services/YLoc/webloc.cgi), an interpretable web server for predicting the subcellular localization of proteins [59, 60].
Phylogenetic analysis of ATG genes
To further investigate the evolutionary relationships of among the ATG proteins in various plants species, the phylogenetic trees of the ATG genes were constructed. Multiple sequence alignment of ATG protein sequences were conducted with the ClustalX 1.81 program using the default multiple alignment parameters. The unrooted phylogenetic tree were constructed using MEGA5.0 software with a maximum likelihood method using sequences from S. italica (Si), N. tabacum (Nt), A. thaliana (At), O. sativa (Os), and Z. mays (Zm) [16–19, 61]. Bootstrap analysis was performed with 1000 replicates to obtain a support value for each branch.
Chromosomal location, gene structure analysis, and estimation of genomic distribution
All SiATG genes were mapped onto the nine foxtail millet chromosomes according to their ascending order of physical position (bp), from the short arm telomere to the long arm telomere, these were visualized using MapChart . The exon-intron structures of the SiATG genes were determined by comparing the coding sequences (CDS) with their corresponding genomic sequences using the Gene Structure Display Server (GSDS) (http://gsds.cbi.pku.edu.cn/). Sequence duplications in foxtail millet, and the synteny between foxtail millet and rice, were established using the SynMap tool (https://genomevolution.org/CoGe/SynMap.pl) with the following settings: Blast Algorithm-Last, DAG Chainer options, and Merge syntenic Blocks, using the recommended parameters. Existing tandem duplications of the ATG genes in the foxtail millet genome were identified by manually evaluating the physical locations of genes within a region of 200 kb.
Estimation of the synonymous and non-synonymous substitution rates of the ATG genes
Synonymous (Ks) and non-synonymous (Ka) substitution rates were estimated according to previously-described criteria . Ks and Ka substitution rates were calculated using the CODEML program and confirmed with the GEvo tool (https://genomevolution.org/CoGe/SynMap.pl). The time (million years ago, MYA) of duplication and divergence time (T) was calculated using a synonymous mutation rate of λ substitutions per synonymous site per year as T = Ks/2λ (λ = 6.5 × 10−9) [64, 65].
Total RNA isolation and quantitative real-time PCR
Total RNA from foxtail millet was isolated using Trizol reagent (Invitrogen, USA) according to the manufacturer’s instructions. The integrity of the RNA was confirmed by electrophoresis with 1.2 % agarose gels. The relative expression levels of the SiATG genes under various treatments were examined using quantitative real-time PCR (qRT-PCR). For each plant sample, 5μg of total RNA was reverse transcribed to cDNA in a 50μl reaction system using a PrimeScript 1st Strand cDNA Synthesis Kit (Transgen Biotech. Beijing, China). The primers for the qRT-PCR analysis were designed from a non-conserved region using Primer-BLAST (http://0-www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov.brum.beds.ac.uk/tools/primer-blast/). Reverse primers were designed preferentially from the 3’-untranslated region wherever possible, as these regions are, in general, both relatively more unique than the coding sequence and closer to the reverse transcriptase (RT) start site. qRT-PCR was performed with three biological replicates, with three technical replicates per biological replicate. The primers used in these experiments are detailed in Additional file 1: Table S9.
Construction of the SiATG8a gene vector and rice transformation
The SiATG8a coding region was amplified by PCR using the primers F1 (BamH I) and R1 (Sac I). The PCR product was then digested and ligated into the binary vector pMWB014 (driven by a ubiquitin promoter) to obtain the construct pMWB014-SiATG8a. This construct was transformed into Oryza sativa cv. Kitaake using Agrobacterium-mediated transformation . Fifty transgenic rice lines were generated and confirmed by PCR using the F2 and R2 primers. Nine transgenic lines were analyzed for phenotypes. Similar phenotypes were observed for these nine lines, and data from three of these selected lines were chosen for presentation here. The transcription level of SiATG8a in the three selected transgenic rice lines was analyzed via qRT-PCR. The primers used in this analysis are detailed in Additional file 1: Table S10. The transcription levels of the endogenous ATG (i.e., OsATG) in the three selected transgenic rice lines and in wild-type rice were verified by qRT-PCR. The primers used in this analysis are detailed in Additional file 1: Table S11.
Phenotypic analysis and measurement of nitrogen and protein content in transgenic rice plants
Seedlings of transgenic rice were grown in the greenhouse under a 16/8 photoperiod at 30 °C. For the nitrogen-free treatment experiment, 3-week-old seedlings of control rice and transgenic rice plants grown in normal Hoagland solution conditions were sub-cultured in nitrogen-deficient liquid medium (Hoagland hydroponic solution (pH 5.5), 5 mM KNO3, 5 mM Ca(NO3)2, 2 mM MgSO4, 1 mM NH4NO3). The nitrogen-free solution was prepared by replacing KNO3 and Ca(NO3)2 with KCl and CaCl2, respectively. After nitrogen starvation, plants that had green and healthy young leaves were considered to have survived, and the survival rate was calculated, using two green leaves as the standard for survival estimate. All experiments were repeated independently three times, and data were analyzed by Dunnett’s Test at the P ≤ 0.05 level. Total nitrogen content was determined by the Kjeldahl method . Protein content was measured using the Bradford method .
The foxtail millet varieties were kindly provided by Prof. Diao Xian-Min, Institute of Crop sciences, Chinese Academy of Agricultural Sciences, Beijing, China. We are also grateful to Dr. John Hugh Snyder for help revise the manuscript.
This work was supported by the National Key Project for Research on Transgenic Biology [2016ZX08002-005], Beijing science and technology project [Z141100002314018] and the Graduate Innovation Fund of Harbin Normal University [HSDBSCX2012-04]. MJH and Rothamsted Research are supported via the 20:20 Wheat® Programme by the UK Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council.
Availability of data and materials
All relevant data of this article are available within the manuscript and its additional files. Nucleic acid sequence of SiATG8a has been deposited in NCBI GenBank under accessions number KX539300 and the accession numbers of other putative protein sequences using analysis are available in the NCBI database (http://0-www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov.brum.beds.ac.uk/protein/) and provided in Additional file 1: Table S1.
WW L conducted the bioinformatic work, generated and analyzed data, and wrote the manuscript. MC conceived and designed experiments, and edited the manuscript. EHW, LQH, LZ, and ZC helped to carried out experiments and analyzed data. MH participated in the study design and helped to draft the manuscript. ZSX, LCL, and YBZ provided reagents. CHG and YZM contributed with valuable discussions. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Consent for publication
Ethics approval and consent to participate
Open AccessThis article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated.
- Thompson AR, Vierstra RD. Autophagic recycling: lessons from yeast help define the process in plants. Curr Opin Plant Biol. 2005;8(2):165–73.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Yoshimoto K, Takano Y, Sakai Y. Autophagy in plants and phytopathogens. FEBS Lett. 2010;584(7):1350–8.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Kanki T, Wang K, Baba M, Bartholomew CR, Lynch-Day MA, Du Z, Geng JF, Mao K, Yang ZF, Yen WL, et al. A Genomic Screen for Yeast Mutants Defective in Selective Mitochondria Autophagy. Mol Biol Cell. 2009;20(22):4730–8.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Yao ZY, Delorme-Axford E, Backues SK, Klionsky DJ. Atg41/Icy2 regulates autophagosome formation. Autophagy. 2015;11(12):2288–99.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Mizushima N. Autophagy: process and function. Gene Dev. 2007;21(22):2861–73.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Okamoto K, Kondo-Okamoto N, Ohsumi Y. Mitochondria-anchored receptor Atg32 mediates degradation of mitochondria via selective autophagy. Dev Cell. 2009;17(1):87–97.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Suzuki K, Kondo C, Morimoto M, Ohsumi Y. Selective transport of alpha-mannosidase by autophagic pathways identification of a novel receptor, Atg34p. J Biol Chem. 2010;285(39):30019–25.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Tsukada M, Ohsumi Y. Isolation and characterization of autophagy-defective mutants of Saccharomyces cerevisiae. FEBS Lett. 1993;333(1–2):169–74.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Thumm M, Egner R, Koch B, Schlumpberger M, Straub M, Veenhuis M, Wolf DH. Isolation of autophagocytosis mutants of Saccharomyces cerevisiae. FEBS Lett. 1994;349(2):275–80.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Harding TM, Morano KA, Scott SV, Klionsky DJ. Isolation and Characterization of yeast mutants in the cytoplasm to vacuole protein targeting pathway. J Cell Biol. 1995;131(3):591–602.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Noda T, Suzuki K, Ohsumi Y. Yeast autophagosomes: de novo formation of a membrane structure. Trends Cell Bio. 2002;12(5):231–5.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Wang CW, Klionsky DJ. The molecular mechanism of autophagy. Mol Med. 2003;9(3–4):65–76.PubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Klionsky DJ, Cregg JM, Dunn WA, Emr SD, Sakai Y, Sandoval IV, Sibirny A, Subramani S, Thumm M, Veenhuis M, et al. A unified nomenclature for yeast autophagy-related genes. Dev Cell. 2003;5(4):539–45.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Su W, Ma HJ, Liu C, Wu JX, Yang JS. Identification and characterization of two rice autophagy associated genes, OsAtg8 and OsAtg4. Mol Biol Rep. 2006;33(4):273–8.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Chung T, Suttangkakul A, Vierstra RD. The ATG autophagic conjugation system in maize: ATG transcripts and abundance of the ATG8-lipid adduct are regulated by development and nutrient availability. Plant Physiol. 2009;149(1):220–34.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Xia KF, Liu T, Ouyang J, Wang R, Fan T, Zhang MY. Genome-wide identification, classification, and expression analysis of autophagy-associated gene homologues in rice (Oryza sativa L.). DNA Res. 2011;18(5):363–77.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Li FQ, Chung T, Pennington JG, Federico ML, Kaeppler HF, Kaeppler SM, Otegui MS, Vierstra RD. Autophagic Recycling Plays a Central Role in Maize Nitrogen Remobilization. Plant Cell. 2015;27(5):1389–408.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Il Kwon S, Park OK. Autophagy in plants. J Plant Biol. 2008;51(5):313–20.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Zhou XM, Zhao P, Wang W, Zou J, Cheng TH, Peng XB, Sun MX. A comprehensive, genome-wide analysis of autophagy-related genes identified in tobacco suggests a central role of autophagy in plant response to various environmental cues. DNA Res. 2015;22(4):245–57.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Liu Y, Schiff M, Czymmek K, Talloczy Z, Levine B, Dinesh-Kumar SP. Autophagy regulates programmed cell death during the plant innate immune response. Cell. 2005;121(4):567–77.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Xiang Y, Contento AL, Bassham D. Disruption of autophagy results in constitutive oxidative stress in Arabidopsis. Autophagy. 2007;3(3):257–8.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Xiong Y, Contento AL, Nguyen PQ, Bassham DC. Degradation of oxidized proteins by autophagy during oxidative stress in Arabidopsis. Plant Physiol. 2007;143(1):291–9.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Chung T, Phillips AR, Vierstra RD. ATG8 lipidation and ATG8-mediated autophagy in Arabidopsis require ATG12 expressed from the differentially controlled ATG12A and ATG12B loci. Plant J. 2010;62(3):483–93.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Wada S, Hayashida Y, Izumi M, Kurusu T, Hanamata S, Kanno K, Kojima S, Yamaya T, Kuchitsu K, Makino A, et al. Autophagy Supports Biomass Production and Nitrogen Use Efficiency at the Vegetative Stage in Rice. Plant Physiol. 2015;168(1):60–U721.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Xiong Y, Contento AL, Bassham DC. AtATG18a is required for the formation of autophagosomes during nutrient stress and senescence in Arabidopsis thaliana. Plant J. 2005;42(4):535–46.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Doelling JH, Walker JM, Friedman EM, Thompson AR, Vierstra RD. The APG8/12-activating enzyme APG7 is required for proper nutrient recycling and senescence in Arabidopsis thaliana. J Biol Chem. 2002;277(36):33105–14.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Thompson AR, Doelling JH, Suttangkakul A, Vierstra RD. Autophagic nutrient recycling in Arabidopsis directed by the ATG8 and ATG12 conjugation pathways. Plant Physiol. 2005;138(4):2097–110.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Bassham DC. Plant autophagy-more than a starvation response. Curr Opin Plant Biol. 2007;10(6):587–93.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Hanaoka H, Noda T, Shirano Y, Kato T, Hayashi H, Shibata D, Tabata S, Ohsumi Y. Leaf senescence and starvation-induced chlorosis are accelerated by the disruption of an Arabidopsis autophagy gene. Plant Physiol. 2002;129(3):1181–93.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Xie ZP, Nair U, Klionsky DJ. Atg8 controls phagophore expansion during autophagosome formation. Mol Biol Cell. 2008;19(8):3290–8.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Nakatogawa H, Ichimura Y, Ohsumi Y. Atg8, a ubiquitin-like protein required for autophagosome formation, mediates membrane tethering and hemifusion. Cell. 2007;130(1):165–78.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Yoshimoto K, Hanaoka H, Sato S, Kato T, Tabata S, Noda T, Ohsumi Y. Processing of ATG8s, ubiquitin-like proteins, and their deconjugation by ATG4s are essential for plant autophagy. Plant Cell. 2004;16(11):2967–83.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Woo J, Park E, Dinesh-Kumar SP. Differential processing of Arabidopsis ubiquitin-like Atg8 autophagy proteins by Atg4 cysteine proteases (vol 111, pg 863, 2013). Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2014;111(25):9325.Google Scholar
- Slavikova S, Shy G, Yao YL, Giozman R, Levanony H, Pietrokovski S, Elazar Z, Galili G. The autophagy-associated Atg8 gene family operates both under favourable growth conditions and under starvation stresses in Arabidopsis plants. J Exp Bot. 2005;56(421):2839–49.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Kuzuoglu-Ozturk D, Yalcinkaya OC, Akpinar BA, Mitou G, Korkmaz G, Gozuacik D, Budak H. Autophagy-related gene, TdAtg8, in wild emmer wheat plays a role in drought and osmotic stress response. Planta. 2012;236(4):1081–92.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Slavikova S, Ufaz S, Avin-Wittenberg T, Levanony H, Galili G. An autophagy-associated Atg8 protein is involved in the responses of Arabidopsis seedlings to hormonal controls and abiotic stresses. J Exp Bot. 2008;59(14):4029–43.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Xia TM, Xiao D, Liu D, Chai WT, Gong QQ, Wang NN. Heterologous expression of ATG8c from soybean confers tolerance to nitrogen deficiency and increases yield in Arabidopsis. Plos One. 2012;7(5):e37217.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Bennetzen JL, Schmutz J, Wang H, Percifield R, Hawkins J, Pontaroli AC, Estep M, Feng L, Vaughn JN, Grimwood J, et al. Reference genome sequence of the model plant Setaria. Nat Biotechnol. 2012;30(6):555–61.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Zhang GY, Liu X, Quan ZW, Cheng SF, Xu X, Pan SK, Xie M, Zeng P, Yue Z, Wang WL, et al. Genome sequence of foxtail millet (Setaria italica) provides insights into grass evolution and biofuel potential. Nat Biotechnol. 2012;30(6):549–54.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Jia GQ, Huang XH, Zhi H, Zhao Y, Zhao Q, Li WJ, Chai Y, Yang LF, Liu KY, Lu HY, et al. A haplotype map of genomic variations and genome-wide association studies of agronomic traits in foxtail millet (Setaria italica). Nat Genet. 2013;45(8):957–61.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Kellogg EA. Evolutionary history of the grasses. Plant Physiol. 2001;125(3):1198–205.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Zhang YC, Mao LY, Wang H, Brocker C, Yin XJ, Vasiliou V, Fei ZJ, Wang XP. Genome-wide identification and analysis of grape aldehyde dehydrogenase (ALDH) gene superfamily. Plos One. 2012;7(2):e32153.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Chardon F, Noel V, Masclaux-Daubresse C. Exploring NUE in crops and in Arabidopsis ideotypes to improve yield and seed quality. J Exp Bot. 2012;63(9):3401–12.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Guiboileau A, Yoshimoto K, Soulay F, Bataille MP, Avice JC, Masclaux-Daubresse C. Autophagy machinery controls nitrogen remobilization at the whole-plant level under both limiting and ample nitrate conditions in Arabidopsis. New Phytol. 2012;194(3):732–40.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Guiboileau A, Avila-Ospina L, Yoshimoto K, Soulay F, Azzopardi M, Marmagne A, Lothier J, Masclaux-Daubresse C. Physiological and metabolic consequences of autophagy deficiency for the management of nitrogen and protein resources in Arabidopsis leaves depending on nitrate availability. New Phytol. 2013;199(3):683–94.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Vision TJ, Brown DG, Tanksley SD. The origins of genomic duplications in Arabidopsis. Science. 2000;290(5499):2114–7.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Pennisi E. Evolutionary biology - Twinned genes live life in the fast lane. Science. 2000;290(5494):1065–6.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Juretic N, Hoen DR, Huynh ML, Harrison PM, Bureau TE. The evolutionary fate of MULE-mediated duplications of host gene fragments in rice. Genome Res. 2005;15(9):1292–7.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Lyons E, Pedersen B, Kane J, Alam M, Ming R, Tang HB, Wang XY, Bowers J, Paterson A, Lisch D, et al. Finding and comparing syntenic regions among Arabidopsis and the outgroups papaya, poplar, and grape: CoGe with rosids. Plant Physiol. 2008;148(4):1772–81.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Xu G, Guo C, Shan H, Kong H. Divergence of duplicate genes in exon-intron structure. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2012;109(4):1187–92.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Ahuja I, de Vos RC, Bones AM, Hall RD. Plant molecular stress responses face climate change. Trends Plant Sci. 2010;15(12):664–74.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Puranik S, Sahu PP, Mandal SN, Suresh BV, Parida SK, Prasad M. Comprehensive Genome-wide survey, genomic constitution and expression profiling of the NAC transcription factor family in foxtail millet (Setaria italic L.). Plos One. 2013;8(5):e64594.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Zhu JK. Cell signaling under salt, water and cold stresses. Curr Opin Plant Biol. 2001;4(5):401–6.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Tsugane K, Kobayashi K, Niwa Y, Ohba Y, Wada K, Kobayashi H. A recessive arabidopsis mutant that grows photoautotrophically under salt stress shows enhanced active oxygen detoxification. Plant Cell. 1999;11(7):1195–206.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Shin JH, Yoshimoto K, Ohsumi Y, Jeon JS, An G. OsATG10b, an autophagosome component, is needed for cell survival against oxidative stresses in rice. Mol Cells. 2009;27(1):67–74.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Rose TL, Bonneau L, Der C, Marty-Mazars D, Marty F. Starvation-induced expression of autophagy-related genes in Arabidopsis. Biol Cell. 2006;98(1):53–67.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Puranik S, Bahadur RP, Srivastava PS, Prasad M. Molecular cloning and characterization of a membrane associated NAC family gene, SiNAC from foxtail millet [Setaria italica (L.) P. Beauv.]. Mol Biotechnol. 2011;49(2):138–50.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Puranik S, Jha S, Srivastava PS, Sreenivasulu N, Prasad M. Comparative transcriptome analysis of contrasting foxtail millet cultivars in response to short-term salinity stress. J Plant Physiol. 2011;168(3):280–7.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Briesemeister S, Rahnenfuhrer J, Kohlbacher O. Going from where to why-interpretable prediction of protein subcellular localization. Bioinformatics. 2010;26(9):1232–8.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Briesemeister S, Rahnenfuhrer J, Kohlbacher O. YLoc-an interpretable web server for predicting subcellular localization. Nucleic Acids Res. 2010;38:W497–502.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Tamura K, Peterson D, Peterson N, Stecher G, Nei M, Kumar S. MEGA5: Molecular evolutionary genetics analysis using maximum likelihood, evolutionary distance, and maximum parsimony methods. Mol Biol Evol. 2011;28(10):2731–9.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Voorrips RE. MapChart: Software for the graphical presentation of linkage maps and QTLs. J Hered. 2002;93(1):77–8.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Chen Z, Chen M, Xu ZS, Li LC, Chen XP, Ma YZ. Characteristics and expression patterns of the aldehyde dehydrogenase (ALDH) gene superfamily of foxtail millet (Setaria italica L.). Plos One. 2014;9(7):e101136.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Lynch M, Conery JS. The evolutionary fate and consequences of duplicate genes. Science. 2000;290(5494):1151–5.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Yang ZF, Gu SL, Wang XF, Li WJ, Tang ZX, Xu CW. Molecular evolution of the CPP-like gene family in plants: Insights from comparative genomics of Arabidopsis and rice. J Mol Evol. 2008;67(3):266–77.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Hiei Y, Ohta S, Komari T, Kumashiro T. Efficient transformation of rice (Oryza sativa L.) mediated by Agrobacterium and sequence analysis of the boundaries of the T-DNA. Plant J. 1994;6(2):271–82.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Li YL, Fan XR, Shen QR. The relationship between rhizosphere nitrification and nitrogen-use efficiency in rice plants. Plant Cell Environ. 2008;31(1):73–85.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Carlsson N, Borde A, Wolfel S, Akerman B, Larsson A. Quantification of protein concentration by the Bradford method in the presence of pharmaceutical polymers. Anal Biochem. 2011;411(1):116–21.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar