- Research article
- Open Access
Inter-genome comparison of the Quorn fungus Fusarium venenatum and the closely related plant infecting pathogen Fusarium graminearum
BMC Genomics volume 19, Article number: 269 (2018)
The soil dwelling saprotrophic non-pathogenic fungus Fusarium venenatum, routinely used in the commercial fermentation industry, is phylogenetically closely related to the globally important cereal and non-cereal infecting pathogen F. graminearum. This study aimed to sequence, assemble and annotate the F. venenatum (strain A3/5) genome, and compare this genome with F. graminearum.
Using shotgun sequencing, a 38,660,329 bp F. venenatum genome was assembled into four chromosomes, and a 78,618 bp mitochondrial genome. In comparison to F. graminearum, the predicted gene count of 13,946 was slightly lower. The F. venenatum centromeres were found to be 25% smaller compared to F. graminearum. Chromosome length was 2.8% greater in F. venenatum, primarily due to an increased abundance of repetitive elements and transposons, but not transposon diversity. On chromosome 3 a major sequence rearrangement was found, but its overall gene content was relatively unchanged. Unlike homothallic F. graminearum, heterothallic F. venenatum possessed the MAT1–1 type locus, but lacked the MAT1–2 locus. The F. venenatum genome has the type A trichothecene mycotoxin TRI5 cluster, whereas F. graminearum has type B. From the F. venenatum gene set, 786 predicted proteins were species-specific versus NCBI. The annotated F. venenatum genome was predicted to possess more genes coding for hydrolytic enzymes and species-specific genes involved in the breakdown of polysaccharides than F. graminearum. Comparison of the two genomes reduced the previously defined F. graminearum-specific gene set from 741 to 692 genes. A comparison of the F. graminearum versus F. venenatum proteomes identified 15 putative secondary metabolite gene clusters (SMC), 109 secreted proteins and 38 candidate effectors not found in F. venenatum. Five of the 15 F. graminearum-specific SMCs that were either absent or highly divergent in the F. venenatum genome showed increased in planta expression. In addition, two predicted F. graminearum transcription factors previously shown to be required for fungal virulence on wheat plants were absent or exhibited high sequence divergence.
This study identifies differences between the F. venenatum and F. graminearum genomes that may contribute to contrasting lifestyles, and highlights the repertoire of F. graminearum-specific candidate genes and SMCs potentially required for pathogenesis.
The genus Fusarium contains numerous destructive and toxigenic filamentous ascomycete fungi that pose a current, and growing threat, to plant, animal, human and ecosystem health. Prominent plant diseases caused by Fusaria include, Fusarium head blight (FHB) of cereals [1, 2], sudden death syndrome of soybeans , and vascular wilts of numerous important crops, such as banana, tomato and oil palm . The negative impact of Fusarium-induced yield losses is compounded by the contamination of the crop with various mycotoxins, making the harvest unsuitable for human or animal consumption. Additionally, Fusaria can cause opportunistic, and life-threatening, infections of immunocompromised humans . Other Fusaria are non-pathogenic and have a saprophytic or endophytic lifestyle . The close phylogenetic relationships but diverse array of fungal lifestyles present within Fusaria are ideal for the identification of the genetic factors contributing to the occupancy of various biological and environmental niches, and the evolution of different lifestyles.
Fusarium head blight disease, also known as Fusarium head scab in the United States and elsewhere, is caused by up to 17 related Fusarium species and occurs on all small grain cereals throughout the globe. Within Europe, the USA, China, Brazil and elsewhere, the main causal organism on wheat, barley and maize crops is F. graminearum. FHB is the number one floral disease affecting wheat crops and is a serious health hazard, due to direct crop losses and the contamination of the grain with type B trichothecene mycotoxins, such as deoxynivalenol (DON) and nivalenol [1, 2]. Altered agronomic practices have failed to reduce inoculum levels, while fungicides only provide modest crop protection, and fully FHB-resistant wheat and barley cultivars have not been realised. Consequently, new approaches to control FHB are needed to improve grain yield, quality and safety.
At present, F. graminearum is known to secrete a cocktail of enzymatic and non-enzymatic proteinaceous virulence factors in combination with host and non-host specific, toxic and non-toxic, metabolites into the plant tissue to manipulate the host and to obtain nutrition . The independent loss of the secretion of i) the DON mycotoxin , ii) the iron scavenging triacetylfusarinine C (TAFC) siderophore , or iii) the Fgl1 lipase , results in a dramatic reduction in virulence, demonstrating that each secreted biologically active compound is required for full infection. Other unknown fungal compounds, metabolites and proteins potentially contribute to the establishment of infection and disease progression. Recent advancements have improved the understanding of the infection biology of F. graminearum in wheat [11, 12], fungal virulence factor requirements [8,9,10, 13] and some of the underlying plant resistance mechanisms . However, an increased understanding of the evolution of F. graminearum as a pathogen of cereals may accelerate the rate of discovery of additional virulence determinants, and assist in the development of novel crop protection strategies.
Fusarium venenatum A3/5 is a ubiquitous saprophytic, soil-dwelling fungus, which was initially misclassified as Fusarium graminearum A3/5, prior to the utilisation of molecular phylogenetic techniques . In the 1980’s, F. venenatum was developed as a protein-rich alternative to meat, which was low in fat and high in dietary fibre, and subsequently commercialised under the name Quorn® [16,17,18]. The production of Quorn, involves fungal biomass accumulation in fermenters under specific growth conditions, which is then heated, mixed with egg albumin or potato starch, and rolled into meat-like fibres. To date, Quorn remains the only fungal-derived protein source (myco-protein) that is commercially available and approved for human consumption, throughout the world. Industrially, F. venenatum has also been widely used as a biological system for the production of recombinant proteins, including trypsin, lipases, phytases and xylanases [19,20,22]. Therefore, the saprophyte F. venenatum has become an economically important microbial cell factory for the production of myco-protein and either industrial or food grade enzymes. No detectable toxins are found in any of the fermentation products. However, F. venenatum has been shown to produce the type A trichothecene, diacetoxyscirpenol (DAS) toxin in inoculated rice grain cultures .
Single species genomics when combined with comparative genomics is a powerful tool to study how fungi have adapted to occupy their environmental niche(s), through the acquisition, loss, or diversification of annotated/unannotated protein families and/or chromosomal regions. Sequencing of the F. graminearum genome  revealed few repetitive sequences, due to an active repeat-induced point mutation mechanism, and polymorphic regions located near telomeres and at several other genome locations which were proposed to represent ancient chromosomal fusion events. These polymorphic regions were found to be enriched for genes, either highly expressed in planta, predicted to code for secreted proteins, or genes confirmed to be involved in pathogenic interactions with plants . Subsequently, the comparison of the genomes from F. graminearum with Fusarium oxysporum f. sp. lycopersici (Fol), a pathogen of tomato, and Fusarium verticillioides, a pathogen of maize, revealed the existence of small lineage-specific chromosomes in Fol, which conferred pathogenicity . This demonstrates the value of comparative genomics to study the evolution of pathogenesis and for the discovery of novel virulence determinants. The recent completion of the F. graminearum genome from telomere-to-telomere now provides an excellent resource for further interspecies comparisons .
In this study, we present a genomic comparison of the closely related non-pathogenic and pathogenic Fusaria, respectively F. venenatum and F. graminearum. Our analyses revealed the striking genetic and genomic similarities between the two species and have revealed the minimal gene set specific to the pathogenic lifestyle of F. graminearum. The predicted number of F. venentaum and F. graminearum gene models, hereafter referred to as genes (13,946 vs 14,164), and the GC content (47.6 vs 48) were very similar between species. Similarly, the macro- and microsynteny between the two genomes was very high, except for a region on chromosome 3 where a large rearrangement and reorientation was found. A similar genome rearrangement was also found in the closely related species, F. poae . The genomic comparison revealed the trichothecene mycotoxin TRI5 gene cluster resides at the same location on chromosome 2 in both species with F. venenatum possessing the type A and F. graminearum the type B. The TRI1/TRI16 cluster is located at the same location on chromosome 1 in both species, but only F. venenatum is predicted to possess a functional copy of TRI16. The F. venenatum genome was predicted to possess a greater number of genes coding for hydrolytic enzymes and species-specific genes involved in the breakdown of polysaccharides in a pair-wise analysis. Both attributes would potentially facilitate a solely saprophytic lifestyle in soil and within an industrial fermenter
Further analysis reduced the previously defined F. graminearum-specific gene set  from 741 to 692 genes, with the additional comparisons to F. culmorum and F. poae reducing this number further to 690. Of these 690, there are five secreted proteins with no known annotation and three candidate effectors. A comparison of the proteomes of F. graminearum vs F. venenatum identified 15 putative secondary metabolite gene clusters, 109 secreted proteins, 38 candidate effectors not found in F. venenatum. Exploring the genome for F. graminearum homologues of 160 genes proven to be required for virulence using the pathogen-host interactions database (PHI-base) [27, 28], revealed only two genes annotated as transcription factors with a reduced virulence phenotype were absent in F. venenatum versus F. graminearum. There was no difference in genes annotated with loss of pathogenicity. This genomic comparison of closely related pathogenic and non-pathogenic Fusarium species highlights the repertoire of F. graminearum specific candidate genes and secondary metabolite clusters potentially required for pathogenesis.
Assessment of Fusarium venenatum pathogenicity on wheat and tomato
To confirm that F. venenatum was not pathogenic on wheat, in contrast to F. graminearum, macrospores of both species were generated on potato dextrose agar plates. Wheat heads were drop- and spray-inoculated at anthesis. Disease development and grain formation were assessed at 16 and 21 days post infection (see Additional file 1). In these tests, F. venenatum was not able to cause visible disease symptoms on wheat heads, while F. graminearum caused significant wheat head bleaching and the abortion of grain development. A very small amount of F. venenatum hyphal growth was evident solely on the wheat anthers 2–3 days post inoculation, but this growth did not persist.
To assess whether F. venenatum could cause a post-harvest disease on tomato (Solanum lycopersicum), ripe fruits were ‘pin-prick’ wounded and inoculated with either F. venenatum or F. graminearum conidia. In this bioassay, F. graminearum rapidly colonised the tomato pericarp within 4 days and developed an abundance of extruding, dry, aerial mycelia. In contrast, F. venenatum showed limited ability to colonise tomato fruits and visible ‘water soaked’ mycelia could only be observed after a prolonged 12-day incubation. However, F. venenatum, was fully able to proliferate on plant-derived nutrient sources contained within agar media, such as carrot and potato dextrose agar. Both bioassays revealed that F. venenatum has a very limited ability to colonise living plant tissues compared to F. graminearum.
These in planta results raised the possibility that F. venenatum could be used as a biocontrol agent to inhibit growth of pathogenic Fusarium species. This hypothesis was tested in a series of co-cultivation experiments. First F. venenatum was co-inoculated on carrot agar plates with three wheat-pathogenic Fusarium strains, FgPH-1, Fg602 and FcUK99. A zone of vegetative incompatibility  was observed between all isolates (see Additional file 2). The extent of the zone of inhibition for F. venenatum was no different to the zones observed between other F. graminearum strains. Next flowering wheat heads were co-inoculated with F. venenatum and F. culmorum conidia. The F. culmorum UK99 strain was chosen as the pathogen in the co-inoculation experiments, because both FcUK99 and the sequenced F. venenatum strain had originally been isolated in the United Kingdom and at the time of isolation F. culmorum was the sole FHB causing species in UK wheat crops. Three types of in planta experiments were done. Firstly, F. culmorum and F. venenatum conidia where mixed in equal amounts and co-inoculated into two spikelets at anthesis. Secondly, F. venenatum conidia were sprayed onto wheat heads at the boot stage to potentially prime plant defence responses, followed by point-inoculation of two spikelets per head with F. culmorum conidia at anthesis. Thirdly, F. culmorum was point-inoculated at anthesis and immediately sprayed a second time with F. venenatum conidia. Disease progress was monitored over 20 days. No inhibition of FHB disease development was observed in these co-inoculation experiments (see Additional file 2). Therefore, we conclude that F. venenatum is not a biocontrol agent for FHB disease caused by F. culmorum.
Assembly and comparative genomics of the Fusarium venenatum genome
An Illumina 100 bp pair-end read approach was taken to sequence the genome. De novo assembly of the F. venenatum genome from telomere-to-telomere, with 137× coverage, resulted in a 38,660,329 bp genome, which assembled into four chromosomes, and a 78,618 bp mitochondrial genome. At present 37 gaps remain within the genome, while one supercontig of 9545 bp was unplaced which contained three genes consisting of a transcription factor (FVRRES_13944), a cholinesterase (FVRRES_13945), and a negative transcriptional regulator (FVRRES_13946), These three genes were not found in F. graminearum but were found in F. oxysporum. This is also the situation for many of the other genes specific to F. venenatum vs F. graminearum where a BLASTP hit was found in F. oxysporum. The GC content was 47.6%, which is comparable to 48% for F. graminearum . Gene modelling was performed using Maker2 , yielding 13,946 genes. Average gene coding length in F. venenatum and F. graminearum was respectively 1388 vs. 1372 bp, with 2.78 vs. 2.76 exons per gene (average exon and intron length 500, 497 and 71, 74 bp, respectively). The F. venenatum genome sequence and annotation (FV1) has been deposited in the European Nucleotide Archive under accession PRJEB7533 (Table 1).
Previous phylogenetic analyses based on the RNA polymerases, RPB1 and RPB2, concluded that F. venenatum was situated within the trichothecene type A/B clade, which predated the separation of the type A clade containing F. sporotrichioides and the type B clade containing F. graminearum and F. pseudograminearum . Our analysis confirmed these previous findings but involved a larger cohort of genes. BUSCO was used to identify 904 common proteins however due to a lack of an available genome for F. sporotrichioides, this species was replaced with another type A producer, F. langsethiae (see Additional files 3 and 4). BLASTP top hits of F. venenatum to NCBI identified the greatest number of gene similarities with F. pseudograminearum, see Additional file 5, which is a type B trichothecene producer whereas F. venenatum has previously been shown to be capable of producing the type A trichothecene, (DAS) under specific cultural conditions . The 904 BUSCO common genes did not include the TRI cluster genes and previous research findings from Ward et al. suggested the TRI clusters evolved independently from the rest of the genome . Therefore although using non-TRI cluster genes to designate type A/B may not be considered applicable, our results match those reported by O’Donnell et al. .
Genome completeness, genome length, number of chromosomes, centromere position and GC content, were all very similar for F. venenatum and the closely related pathogen, F. graminearum (Table 1). In addition, considerable synteny was found between the genes predicted to reside either side of the four centromeres predicted for each species (see Additional file 6). However, the centromeres were found to be 25% smaller (Table 1 and Additional file 6). Inter-comparison of the chromosome lengths revealed chromosome length was 2.8% larger in F. venenatum, with chromosome 3 showing the greatest length increase at 7% (Additional file 7). This length increase was mainly caused by an increased presence of repetitive elements and transposon sequences (described in greater detail below). The F. venenatum and F. graminearum genomes also had a comparable set of RNAs (see Additional file 8). The synteny between the F. venenatum and F. graminearum genomes was very high, except for a region on chromosome 3 where three large rearrangements and reorientations were identified within F. graminearum chromosome 3 at positions 1036–2645, 2645–3046 and 3046–3112 kbp (Fig. 1 and Additional file 9). This rearrangement was also found in the closely related species, F. poae (see Additional file 9). No genes have been disrupted in the rearrangement between F. venenatum and F. graminearum. Of the 783 annotated genes in v4.0 and 786 in v5.0 present within this chromosomal region in F. graminearum (1036–3112 kbp) (Additional file 9), one secondary metabolite cluster (C33) which produces the metabolite ferricrocin  is found but this cluster is also present in F. venenatum and F. poae (BLASTP). The presence of this rearrangement in a closely related pathogenic species F. poae, suggests this rearrangement predates the speciation of F. poae and F. venenatum, and its presence per se is not a likely causal reason for F. venenatum loss of virulence.
The quantity but not diversity of repetitive elements including transposon sequences (see Additional file 10) were higher in F. venenatum in comparison to F. graminearum (1.18% total, 0.54% transposon vs 1.03% and 0.29%) and accounts for most of the increase in chromosome length previously described. F. graminearum has been experimentally proven to have an active repeat induced point mutation (RIP) defence mechanism . The presence of the same mechanism in F. venenatum of gene inactivation is partially supported by the presence of an orthologue of the DNA methyltransferase RID (RIP defective) required for RIP in N. crassa [34, 35] and the orthologous neighbouring 10 genes.
The recent evolution of F. graminearum in the homothallic FGSG species complex, means the fungus can produce fruiting bodies in the absence of a compatible partner, and the genome contains functional copies of both the MAT1–1 and MAT1–2 mating loci [23, 31]. The genome of F. venenatum A3/5 strain was found only to possess the MAT1–1 type locus and is likely a heterothallic species (see Additional file 11). However, a sexual stage has not been reported . This requirement for a compatible sexual partner may reduce the frequency of sexual recombination.
These analyses reveal that the overall genome structure of F. venenatum and F. graminearum were very similar, despite their distinct saprophytic and dual saprophytic/pathogenic lifestyles, respectively. Consequently, subtle differences in the evolution of the closely related fungi and their genomes, may influence the outcome of their various interactions with other organisms and/or the environment.
Comparison of F. venenatum and F. graminearum genome annotations
To facilitate interspecies comparisons, the F. venenatum genome was annotated using the identical Maker pipeline with the same gene predictors previously used for the completed F. graminearum genome  thereby generating highly comparable datasets. The exception is that no F. venenatum RNA-seq data was available for use. Instead F. graminearum RNA-seq data was combined with Fusarium proteome evidence to further improve gene prediction. A global BLASTP analysis of the predicted F. venenatum proteome at 10− 5 and at 10− 20 E-value cutoffs to the National Center for Biotechnology Information (NCBI) nr database (1st March 2017) found 786 (99% no BLASTP annotation) and 1149 (94% no BLASTP annotation) unique genes, respectively (see Additional file 12). These F. venenatum species-specific genes in relation to NCBI database contents, are found distributed across all four chromosomes (see Additional file 13).
To explore the F. venenatum genome in greater detail, a comparison of the predicted proteomes of F. venenatum and F. graminearum (BLASTP of proteomes using a cutoff of 50% or 70% coverage from a global alignment for both the query and target) revealed that at 70% coverage, ~ 50% of the proteome was conserved between the two Fusaria, whilst the remainder was identified to be potentially specific to each species or be highly divergent (Fig. 2, Additional file 14). These species-specific sub-proteomes of the two Fusaria predominantly depicted identical functional profiles predicted by gene ontology (biological process annotations) with the exception for F. graminearum encoding proteins involved in orangonitrogen compound metabolic processes, demonstrating as suggested above, a divergence of functionality within these specific functional classes (Fig. 3).
A search for paralogue protein groups (OrthoMCL) confirmed the previous finding that F. graminearum lacks any identifiable paralogues. However, 12 paralogue protein groups (each comprising either two or three proteins), were found in F. venenatum (see Additional file 15). Only one group (group 12) had any known annotation consisting of a basic-leucine zipper transcription factor, while group 2 and 9 contained predicted secreted candidate effector proteins. There are both adjacent gene (neighbours) paralogue groups, near neighbours (within 2–31 genes) and non-neighbour sets (> 100 genes) representing both recent and distant duplication events.
Comparisons with other pathogenic Fusaria and key fungal species
The annotated F. venenatum genome was compared to F. graminearum and seven other ascomycetes with highly contrasting lifestyles using protein domain signatures known to be functionally linked to virulence  within the PHI-base gene set. The additional species selected were the floral maize pathogen F. verticillioides, the floral cereal pathogen F. langsethiae, the tomato root and vascular pathogen F. oxysporum f. sp. lycopersici, the foliar rice pathogen Magnaporthe oryzae, the floral rice pathogen Ustilaginoidea virens, the saprophytic model filamentous ascomycete Neurospora crassa and the soil dwelling biocontrol fungus Trichoderma virens. The F. venenatum genome revealed a predicted functional profile with striking similarity to the floral cereal pathogens F. graminearum, F. verticillioides and F. langsethiae (Table 2). This included hundreds of glycoside hydrolases, pectin lyases and peptidase involved in the deconstruction of plant cell components, plus hundreds of cytochrome P450 involved in secondary metabolism and major facilitator superfamily or ABC-like transporters. The hemibiotrophic foliar rice pathogen M. oryzae also demonstrated a similar functional profile, while presenting diminished pectinolytic potential and a reduced number of putative transporters. The presence of multiple killer toxin homologues was specific to the three cereal infecting Fusaria. Direct comparisons with the model saprophytic fungus N. crassa, revealed F. venenatum to possess a greater hydrolytic potential, an increased capacity to produce secondary metabolites and a far greater number of putative transporters. One possible explanation for these differences is that the saprophytic fungus N. crassa feeds on cellulose and hemicellulose substrates and occupies a very restricted range of plant associated niches in natural ecosystems. Whereas the other Fusaria species invade and extract nutrients from living and dead plant tissue, whilst also having the ability to grow and survive in the soil and thereby occupy a wider range of biological and environmental niches. Possibly, wider niche occupancy by Fusaria and T. virens accounts for the greater number of predicted secondary metabolite clusters and putative transporters in their genomes. Overall, the global functional profile of the annotated genome of the saprophyte F. venenatum showed greater similarity to the closely related pathogenic Fusaria than other ascomycete saprophytes.
In a second analysis, the secondary metabolite clusters were predicted for F. venenatum and inter-compared with F. graminearum. In F. graminearum toxic and non-toxic secondary metabolites, such as mycotoxins and siderophores, are essential for virulence against wheat [7,8,9]. Both F. venenatum and F. graminearum possess in the same location on chromosome 2 the main TRI5 cluster responsible for trichothecene mycotoxin biosynthesis and in the same location on chromosome 1 the TRI1/TRI16 cluster (Fig. 4, Additional file 16). Surrounding both of these TRI clusters, the identical gene order (microsynteny) has been maintained. In addition, F. venenatum possesses the TRI101 and TRI15 genes in the same chromosome location and gene context as in F. graminearum (on chromosomes 3 and 4, respectively). Whereas, only a truncated version of the TRI15R gene is present in F. venenatum at the same location and same gene context on chromosome 1 as in F. graminearum (FGRRES_02451) and F. langsethiae (FLAG1_06027). A copy of the TRI201 gene is located on chromosome 3 in F. venenatum and chromosome 4 in F. graminearum (Additional file 16). Further inspection of the TRI1/TRI16 cluster revealed an inversion in the relative positions of both genes in these two species compared to the order present in F. sporotrichioides and F. langsethiae. In F. graminearum TRI16 is predicted to be truncated. F. venenatum is known to be able to produce DAS, a type A trichothecene, that originates from the same biosynthetic pathway as another type A trichothecene, T-2, which is produced by the cereal pathogen F. sporotrichioides. This is in contrast to the sequenced F. graminearum PH-1 strain that produces the type B trichothecenes DON . Alignment of the TRI5 and the TRI1/16 clusters for these three species revealed the presence of full length copies of the TRI7, TRI13 and TRI16 genes which confirmed F. venenatum to encode TRI clusters reminiscent of type A trichothecene biosynthesis. Hence, as previously found, the phylogenetic relationship of the TRI clusters does not correlate with the species phylogenetics.
A second inter-species comparative analysis identified the presence or absence of pre-identified F. graminearum TRI6 targets previously determined by ChIP-Seq , in F. venenatum using BLASTP. The transcription factor TRI6 is known to be a global regulator of gene expression in F. graminearum both in planta and when the fungus is growing under specific mycotoxin inducing conditions in vitro . Fourteen of the F. graminearum TRI6 targets were found to have a low alignment score of below the query and target threshold of 55% in F. venenatum. These included the following targets: a P450 gene described as involved in secondary metabolism (FGRRES_17130), the TRI7 gene which is truncated in F. graminearum PH-1 but functional in F. venenatum (FGRRES_03533), two genes linked to carbon metabolism (FGRRES_16885 and FGRRES_17740), one gene linked to nitrogen metabolism and energy production (FGRRES_17446), and four genes linked to transcription/translation (FGRRES_03794_M, FGRRES_05017, FGRRES_07187_M and FGRRES_07751_M) and one to cell signalling (FGRRES_03108) (see Additional file 17).
Comparison of the predicted F. venenatum and F. graminearum secretomes
The proteinaceous fungal secretome is of fundamental importance to determine how fungi interact with their environment, whether that be as a saprophyte or a pathogen. The secretion of hydrolytic enzymes is central to the acquisition of alternative nutrient sources by fungi . Additionally, within a pathology context, small secreted proteins that promote a pathogenic interaction are described as fungal effectors . The F. venenatum and F. graminearum secretomes were predicted using an identical pipeline , whilst the candidate effector repertoire was predicted using EffectorP . Within both Fusaria, the secretome and putative effectors encoding genes were found to localise to chromosomal regions of low nucleotide homology (Fig. 1). A sequence homology analysis revealed that most secreted proteins and putative effectors to be conserved between the two Fusaria (see Additional file 18). Therefore, despite the very different lifestyles, most of the secretome (using a cutoff of 50% coverage from a global alignment for both target and query) was present in both the pathogenic and saprophytic Fusaria. This suggests that only a few secreted proteins are specifically involved in the pathogenic lifestyle, while the majority are required for the completion of the disease cycle on plant biomass. F. graminearum had a lower number of species-specific (Fg vs Fv) secretome proteins (109 vs 151 < 50% coverage, 175 vs 247 < 70% coverage), with the number of secreted hydrolytic enzymes and species-specific secreted hydrolytic enzymes accounting for some of this increase in F. venenatum (Fig. 2, Additional file 19). The functional profiles of the species-specific secretomes were very distinct, with the F. venenatum-specific secretome predominantly presenting proteins involved in carbohydrate catabolic and metabolic processes, while the F. graminearum-specific secretome identified proteins involved in oxidation, reduction and pathogenesis-related processes (Fig. 3). The species-specific (Fg vs Fv) secreted proteins annotated to be potentially involved in pathogenesis were also defined as putative effectors, by EffectorP. These included an endo-beta-xylanase and all four KP4 killer toxins present in F. graminearum of which three have adjacent loci. F. venenatum does have three KP4 killer toxin genes annotated (FVRRES_4386, FVRRES_4580 and FVRRES_4581) but these are highly divergent to the F. graminearum set and only two remain clustered. The F. graminearum secreted proteins involved in oxidation-reduction (i.e. EC:220.127.116.11), not present in F. venenatum using a threshold of 50% coverage, included two flavin-adenine dinucleotide (FAD) binding proteins (FGRRES_15982 and FGRRES_10609), and a FAD-linked oxidase (FGRRES_10611). These species-specific differences could potentially reflect adaptations of the two Fusaria to saprophytic and pathogenic lifestyles.
The minimal F. graminearum gene set specific to a pathogenic lifestyle
The identification of the minimal gene set specific to the pathogenic lifestyle in Fusaria represents a powerful tool and a novel dataset for the further evaluation of F. graminearum. An updated set of F. graminearum species-specific genes in relation to NCBI with the addition of F. culmorum UK99, F. poae, and F. venenatum revealed a reduced set of 690 genes from the original 741 reported by King et al.  using a cutoff of 50% identity from a global alignment for both target and query coverage (see Additional file 14). Of these 690 genes, five are predicted to be secreted in version 4.3 of the annotation analysed herein, a recent secretome update (annotation version 5.0 ) has increased this to 11 with eight as putative effectors, but again with no annotation, and 39 genes are found within predicted secondary metabolite clusters. A previous comparative genomic study which included three pathogenic Fusarium species, namely F. graminearum, F. oxysporum f. sp. lycopersici and F. verticillioides, identified 75 genes to be specific to pathogenic fungi and predominately absent from non-pathogenic fungi, while exhibiting signatures of diversifying selection pressure . The majority of these gene lacked any functional annotation and none in F. graminearum were considered to code for transcription factors. The F. venenatum genome was used to further refine this classification. In total, 15 F. graminearum genes could no longer be classified as pathogenicity-associated, due to their presence in F. venenatum with greater than 50% target/query coverage, reducing the number to 60, while a further 44 F. graminearum pathogenicity-associated genes had less than 50% target/query coverage vs F. venenatum. Only 16 of the originally classified F. graminearum pathogenicity-associated genes did not have a BLASTP hit and so were not present in F. venenatum (Table 3, see Additional file 20) [43, 44].
The multi-species pathogen-host interactions database (PHI-base) contains ~ 8600 curated interactions and ~ 4750 genes from peer reviewed literature, providing phenotypic data associated with genetic mutations in pathogens and their impact on virulence, such as loss of pathogenicity, reduced virulence and hypervirulence [45, 46]. The PHI-base homologues in the F. venenatum and F. graminearum genomes were identified and subdivided according to the impact caused by their absence, or reduced function, on the respective pathogen-host interaction (Table 4, Additional file 21). F. graminearum had a higher number of PHI-base homologues than F. venenatum due to the large number of F. graminearum entries within PHI-base (n = 976 genes). However, the overall number of PHI-base homologues defined as being experimentally proven to be involved in virulence, i.e. conferring either a loss of pathogenicity, reduced virulence, increased virulence or an effector phenotype, was comparable for both species. Only two major exceptions were identified, namely the loss of the transcription factors GzZC120 (FGRRES_08028_M) and GzZC305 (FGRRES_00147) (see Additional file 21) whose experimental deletion in F. graminearum resulted in reduced virulence on wheat heads, but no other altered phenotypes . These two predicted transcription factors reside in regions of the F. venenatum genome with a high frequency of transposon sequences. None of the PHI-genes associated with ‘loss in pathogenicity’ annotations were missing from the F. venenatum genome. This demonstrates that the virulence profile of genes known to be involved in pathogenicity are very similar in the two Fusaria. However, the combined loss of these two genes, and potentially others (discussed later), may be important to the lack of pathogenicity.
For F. graminearum a considerable number of genes clusters have either been predicted or demonstrated to be responsible for the production of a range of secondary metabolites . Genes predicted to reside within fungal secondary metabolite gene clusters (SMC) include polyketide synthetases (PKS) and nonribosomal peptide synthetases (NPS) often in association with transcription factors. Additions to the SMC clusters within the F. venenatum and F. graminearum genomes were predicted using the AntiSmash  and SMURF software , using the prior predictions for F. graminearum from Sieber et al.  and F. venenatum BLASTP hits and positional information as a baseline. In total, the F. venenatum and F. graminearum genomes encoded 60 and 69 predicted secondary metabolite clusters (an additional 2 versus Sieber et al), respectively, of which six were specific to F. venenatum and fifteen were specific to F. graminearum (Fig. 1, Additional file 16). Both Fusaria possessed the biosynthetic machinery to produce, secrete and subsequently import the non-toxic iron scavenging extracellular siderophore TAFC. The putative secondary metabolites specific to the pathogenic species, F. graminearum, included two transcription factor containing clusters (C1, C67), two HC-toxin annotated clusters (C2, C61), seven PKS clusters with annotations of prostacyclin, fusarielin, orcinol/orsellinic acid, daunorubicin and the zearalenone mycotoxin (C15, C16, C18, C31, C32, C47, C60) and four NPS containing clusters (C6, C62, C64, C66) (Fig. 1). Due to the changes in gene predictions for the F. graminearum genome (King et al., 2015, ) since the Sieber et al. analysis, seven of the F. graminearum-specific SMC could be expanded in gene content (C02, C16, C31, C32, C47, C60, and C64), whilst nine SMCs identified in both F. graminearum and F. venenatum were expanded in content (C13, C22, C27, C33, C34, C37, C42, C53, C63) (see Additional file 16). The F. venenatum-specific secondary metabolite clusters included the beta-ketoacyl synthase (VC1), lovastatin (VC2), enniatin (VC5) and equisetin (VC6) clusters and a transcription factor and PKS containing clusters (Fig. 1). The species-specific secondary metabolite clusters in both Fusaria were found in regions of low homology proteins/nucleotides, suggesting their localisation within these genomic regions was important to the evolution of novel functions specific to a particular lifestyle. Finally the GC contents of the orthologous clusters were inspected and found to be very similar (median GC content of 49.43 and 49.5% for F. graminearum and F. venenatum, respectively) (see Additional file 16).
Expression of the minimal pathogenesis-specific F. graminearum gene set during infection
Over the past 10 years, transcriptome studies using the same Affymetrix array , have investigated various saprophytic, developmental and in planta phases of the F. graminearum lifecycle on various substrates and host species . In two of the most recent studies the early symptomless and late symptomatic phases of the wheat infection process have been explored during juvenile wheat coleoptile and mature wheat head colonisation and have been used to define the spatial temporal coordination of virulence mechanisms during infection [44, 50, 52]. In total, 690 (395 identified on microarray) genes were found to be specific to F. graminearum when compared using the set predicted in King et al.  using NCBI, plus the F. venenatum, F. poae, and F. culmorum UK99 predicted proteomes. These 395 genes were found to be up-regulated during mature wheat head infection, with the majority (370 genes) showing increased transcript abundance during symptomless wheat head infection, implicating them as potentially being involved in the establishment of disease (Fig. 5, Additional file 22). Interestingly, five of the seven SMC identified to be highly (C16, C31, C64 and C66) or moderately (C02) expressed during the symptomless phase of wheat head colonisation by F. graminearum were found to be absent or highly divergent within the F. venenatum genome (Fig. 5, Additional file 22). Whilst the two other F. graminearum clusters C48 and C47 were predicted to be present in F. venenatum. The combination of comparative genomics between closely related pathogenic and non-pathogenic Fusaria has therefore identified novel F. graminearum genes that are not present in a non-pathogenic relative, and highly expressed during wheat infection, implicating them as potentially contributing to virulence.
The Fusaria represent a large group of economically destructive, mycotoxigenic and non-mycotoxigenic pathogens of plants and animals, in addition to soil dwelling saprophytes often used as microbial cell factories for the production of myco-protein or industrial heterologous proteins [1, 2, 16,17,18,19,20,22]. Comparative genomics is proving to be an essential tool in the identification of the fungal determinants of a pathogenic lifestyle and the occupancy of a particular niche [24, 53]. This study has confirmed that F. venenatum is non-pathogenic when tested on wheat plants and tomato fruit. Herein, we present the interspecies genomic comparison of F. venenatum, a soil-dwelling saprophyte, and the plant pathogen F. graminearum, the etiological agent of FHB disease on cereal crops. This bioinformatics study has revealed striking similarities in the physical organisation and functional content of the genomes of these two closely related Fusaria. This raises the questions, why is F. venenatum not a pathogen, or conversely, what makes F. graminearum a pathogen? One notable distinction between the two genomes was the increased quantity of repetitive elements and transposons in the F. venenatum genome, plus the absence of the MAT1–2 required for homothallic sexual reproduction. This requirement for a complementary sexual partner could increase the retention of repeats. Overall, the genome organisation was very similar between the two Fusaria, with four large chromosomes and centromeres in similar genomic locations, although the predicted centromeres were 25% smaller in size in F. venenatum. The predicted proteome for F. venenatum was slightly smaller (13,946 vs 14,164), potentially due to some non-annotated genes in this first draft genome, and the GC content (47.6%) is in line with other Fusarium species. Overall, to date the F. venenatum genome is the most closely related genome, of a non-pathogenic species, to the important pathogen F. graminearum.
The gene synteny between the two species was very high, except for a 2010 Kbp region on chromosome 3 that contains 783 annotated genes in v4.0 and 786 in v5.0. Within this rearrangement, the C33 ferricrocin secondary metabolic cluster is located. However, this rearrangement did not lead to any gene disruptions. A similar chromosome rearrangement is found in the pathogenic species Fusarium poae, suggesting that this rearrangement predates the speciation of F. poae and F. venenatum. The other seven chromosomal rearrangements were small in size and were located solely in sub-telomeric regions, or in two cases, in regions predicted to be the sites of ancient chromosome fusion events .
The clear majority of the predicted proteins and their functions were conserved between F. venenatum and F. graminearum. In a pair-wise analysis 50% of the predicted proteome at < 70% coverage were considered to be species-specific or highly divergent. However, in a global multiple species analysis using 10− 5 and 10− 20 E-value cutoffs, 786 (99% with no BLASTP annotation) and 1149 (94% with no BLASTP annotation) of the F. venenatum genes were predicted to be unique to this species. The species-specific genes in both Fusaria are distributed throughout their genome. These results highlight the value of using a comparative study of mulitiple closely related Fusarium species to refine the identification of genes specific to a pathogenic or saprophytic lifestyle, with each addition increasing the specificity.
Both the F. venenatum A3/5 and F. graminearum PH-1 strains possess the capacity to produce trichothecene mycotoxins. However, during the fermentative conditions of Quorn production no detectable trichothecenes are present . The genomic comparison revealed the trichothecene mycotoxin TRI5 gene cluster and the TRI1/TRI16 gene cluster to reside at the same chromosomal locations and in the same microsyntenic gene contexts in both species (Fig. 4). This consistent chromosome position and flanking gene microsynteny is also true for TRI101, TRI15 and TRI15R. The presence of functional copies of TRI7, TRI13 and TRI16 in F. venenatum but inactive truncated copies of all three genes in F. graminearum, accounts for F. venenatum producing type A, and F. graminearum type B, trichothecenes.
In the Fusaria, the trichothecene types are divided according to the absence (type A) or presence (type B) of a keto group at the C-8 position on the trichothecene ring. Both type A trichothecenes, such as DAS and T-2 (produced by F. venenatum and F. sporotrichoides, respectively), and type B trichothecenes, such as DON and NIV (produced by F. graminearum), are described as being phytotoxic . Trichothecenes are ribotoxic and induce translational arrest. The T-2 mycotoxin activates MAP kinase signalling and induces cell death in both animals and plants. However, differences in host-susceptibility to specific trichothecenes exist, as unlike the T-2 mycotoxin, DON does not induce cell death at concentrations sufficient to induce translational arrest . In fact, in plant cells, low and high concentrations of DON respectively inhibit apoptosis or induce host cell death [54, 55]. During the establishment of symptomless F. graminearum infections of wheat the main TRI cluster is dramatically up-regulated, while the absence of the ability to produce DON results in an enhanced host response and reduced virulence [11, 12, 44]. Therefore, the toxigenic differences between DAS-producing F. venenatum and DON-producing F. graminearum potentially contribute to the opposing lifestyles of these closely related Fusaria.
Previous phylogenetic studies have found that differences in trichothecene production do not correlate with the general species phylogeny, while polymorphisms within the trichothecene biosynthetic genes are trans-specific, persist through multiple speciation events, and are maintained by balancing selection . Here, the TRI cluster of F. venenatum was reminiscent of other type A trichothecene producers, such as F. sporotrichioides and F. langsethiae, while the rest of the F. venenatum genome showed a far greater reciprocal homology to DON producer F. graminearum. The trichothecene clusters either evolved by vertical inheritance or were transferred horizontally within Fusaria via the transfer of chromosomes between species, or interspecific hybridisation. Horizontal gene transfer presents a mechanism by which fungal genomes can acquire new gene clusters, as may be the case for several other secondary metabolite clusters in F. graminearum [33, 53]. However, there is no evidence of this among TRI genes due to the lack of co-linearity across the non-mycotoxin biosynthetic genes flanking the TRI cluster in trichothecene and non-trichothecene producers, such as F. graminearum and F. oxysporum . In contrast, TRI101 resides outside the TRI cluster and is flanked by the PHO5 and URA7 genes in trichothecene producing Fusaria, while the microsynteny of this region is conserved in non-trichothecene producers, such as F. oxysporum and F. fujikuroi, where TRI101 is dysfunctional . This suggests that TRI101, which is involved in trichothecene biosynthesis and in a self-protection mechanism, was inactivated by the accumulation of mutations, which impacted upon the capacity that produces and withstands trichothecene production. This mechanism of evolution appears to contribute to the distinct trichothecene types in F. venenatum and F. graminearum, as the microsynteny across the region is high, yet TRI7, TRI13 and TRI16 have been inactivated, diverting secondary metabolism towards the biosynthesis of type B trichothecenes in F. graminearum.
The pathogenic profile of a species, as determined by the identification of PHI-base homologues, provides an insight into a species virulence repertoire. This revealed both F. venenatum and F. graminearum possess a virtually identical set of PHI-base genes, with F. venenatum missing two loss-of-virulence but no loss-of-pathogenicity annotated genes. Interestingly the two missing/highly divergent PHI-base genes are predicted to be transcription factors which when deleted in F. graminearum lead to reduce virulence towards wheat heads, but no other altered phenotype . Species-specific genes beyond the known virulence factors, such as the TRI and PHI-base genes, identified a minimal set of pathogenesis-specific genes of unknown function in F. graminearum, where 855 genes were induced during wheat infection, of which 586 were up-regulated during symptomless infection and the establishment of disease. Similarly, five F. graminearum-specific secondary metabolite gene clusters, which were absent from the F. venenatum genome, were co-ordinately induced during wheat infection.
This comparative genomics study of a closely related non-pathogen and pathogen has provided valuable information on the evolutionary relationship between these two Fusaria and insights into adaptations for a pathogenic lifestyle. This refinement of F. graminearum-specific genes associated solely with a pathogenic lifestyle will facilitate the identification of novel genes and gene clusters involved in pathogenesis and the development of novel FHB disease control strategies.
Origin and maintenance of Fusarium strains
The American type culture collection number of F. venenatum A3/5 is ATCC 20334™. The strain was kindly provided by G. D. Robson (British Mycological Society, Manchester, UK). F. graminearum PH-1 (FGSC 9075, origin USA) and F. culmorum FcUK99 (FGSC 10436, origin UK) are available from the Fungal Genetics Stock Center, Kansas City, MO, USA . F. graminearum Fg602 is a UK field strain isolated from diseased wheat in 2006 at Rothamsted Research. All Fusarium strains including F. venenatum A3/5 were routinely propagated on carrot agar plates . Carrot agar was found to support high asexual spore production for F. venenatum throughout this study.
Plant infection and pathogenicity tests on tomato fruits cultivar Moneymaker and wheat (Triticum aestivum) plants of the fully susceptible cultivar Bobwhite followed previously established protocols . For the co-inoculation of F. venenatum A3/5 with the FHB pathogen F. culmorum isolate FcUK99 the wheat inoculation protocol was modified as follows. For spore droplet co-inoculation, equal amounts of spores at 5 × 104 spores/ml in water were mixed. Five ul of the spore mix was pipetted into two spikelets in the mid-section of the wheat spike at Zadoks growth stage 63 . Disease progression was monitored over 20 days. For the F. venenatum pre-spraying experiments, wheat spikes were sprayed, when half the wheat spike emerged from the surrounding flag leaf (Zadoks growth stage 48), approximately three days before inoculation with the FHB pathogen F. culmorum.
Fusarium venenatum A3/5 genomic DNA preparation
Genomic fungal DNA for sequencing was extracted using the CTAB protocol  and purified using a Qiagen Kit (Qiagen Ltd., Crawley, West Sussex, UK). High-quality genomic DNA was then submitted to the Earlham Institute (Norwich, UK) for generation of a 0.8 kb fragment library. The Illumina HiSeq 2000 sequencing platform (San Diego, CA) was used to produce 100 bp paired-end reads .
Assembly and alignment
Reads were not pre-processed. For de novo assembly, the software SOAPdenovo2 (version 2.0.4) was used with different k-mer values: 61–91. Reference sequence statistics were extracted from Tablet and Geneious  (version 9.1 created by Biomatters). Lastz (version 1.02.00) and Mauve (version 2.3.1) was used from within Geneious to align genomic sequences to F. graminearum (ENA study accession: PRJEB5475).
The assembled genome was annotated using the MAKER (version 2.30)  annotation pipeline with RepeatMasker (version 4.0.5) . A F. venenatum specific repeat library was constructed using RepeatModeler (version 1.0.7) and supplied to MAKER for the repeat masking step. Gene calls were generated using FGENESH (version 3.1.2)  using the Fusarium matrix, AUGUSTUS (version 2.7)  using F. graminearum species model, GeneMark  and SNAP , with evidence taking Fusarium reviewed proteins in UNIPROT with the keyword “Fusarium”, ESTs , and trinity assemblies using RNA-seq from the mycelium and spores of PH-1, and wild type Z-3639. This evidence was provided to MAKER as hints to the annotation. Non-coding RNA were identified using default settings with both tRNAscan-SE-1.3.1  and Infernal-1.1 .
Gene statistics, Interproscan domain, GO and enzyme comparisons
Blast2GO V.3.1 was used with Decypher BLASTP searches with an E-value of 0.001 against the NCBI nr database from 27/06/15, filtered using blast2go annotation algorithm with settings, E-value filter 0.000001, Annotation CutOff 55, GO weight 5, Hsp-Hit Coverage CutOff 0, and GO and enzyme code annotated using a local GO database from 07/2015. Interproscan results were imported into blast2go and the GO annotations merged. Annotation statistics were produced using Eval V.2.2.8 and Geneious. The “Assign your proteins to OrthoMCL Groups” tool was used with the predicted protein sequences from the OrthoMCL website  to assign paralogue groups. BUSCO V1.1b1  was used with the 1438 core fungal genes with both Fusaria genomes using default settings.
Secretome identification and effector prediction
Interproscan-55.0 was used to identify signal and transmembrane domains. Proteins smaller than 20 amino acids were excluded. ProtComp (Version 9.0) (Softberry, USA) and result columns, LocDB and PotLocDB were used to exclude GPI anchored membrane proteins and other non-extracellular loci proteins. WoLfPSort  (extracellular score > 17, WoLfPSort) was used to identify final destination and big-PI  to further remove GPI-anchored proteins. Putative effector proteins were predicted using EffectorP (v1.0).
Secondary metabolite cluster analyses
SMURF  and antiSMASH  were used to predict and complement prior published secondary metabolite clusters . Percentage GC content for each cluster were calculated by extracting each clusters gene sequence, including introns, using bedtools, and GC content calculated using EMBOSS infoseq . Median percentage GC content values were taken using Excel.
The BUSCO V1.1b1 fungi database was used with the proteomes of F. solani, F. oxysporum, F. verticillioides, F. mangiferae, F. fujikuroi, F. proliferatum, F. poae, F. venenatum, F. langsethiae, F. graminearum and F. pseudograminearum taken from Ensembl Fungi release 38. The resulting “complete” proteins across the species, subtracting for those that had more than one hit with a BUSCO gene were 904. For each species the proteins were concatenated and an alignment done using MAFFT (V7.222)  in Geneious. RAxML blackbox  was used to create a phylogenetic tree with 100 bootstraps, JTT substitution matrix, a Gamma model of rate heterogeneity, and using a maximum likelihood search. The substitution rate is on each branch and 100% branch support was found from 100 bootstraps.
Sequence Read Archive (SRA) sample accession numbers for Illumina sequences is ERS568866. The RRes genomic and mitochondrial sequence for F. venenatum and F. graminearum are available at the European Nucleotide Archive (ENA Submission) with respective study accessions: PRJEB7533 and PRJEB5475.
Fusarium head blight
Horizontal gene transfer
National Center for Biotechnology Information
Nonribosomal peptide synthetase
Pathogen-Host Interactions database
Polyketide synthase clusters
Repeat induced point mutation
Secondary metabolite gene clusters
Goswami RS, Kistler HC. Heading for disaster: Fusarium graminearum on cereal crops. Mol Plant Pathol. 2004;5(6):515–25.
Dean R, Van Kan JAL, Pretorius ZA, Hammond-Kosack KE, Di Pietro A, Spanu PD, Rudd JJ, Dickman M, Kahmann R, Ellis J, et al. The top 10 fungal pathogens in molecular plant pathology. Mol Plant Pathol. 2012;13(4):414–30.
Roy KW, Rupe JC, Hershman DE, Abney TS. Sudden death syndrome of soybean. Plant Dis. 1997;81(10):1100–11.
Di Pietro A, Madrid MP, Caracuel Z, Delgado-Jarana J, Roncero MIG. Fusarium oxysporum: exploring the molecular arsenal of a vascular wilt fungus. Mol Plant Pathol. 2003;4(5):315–25.
Nucci M, Anaissie E. Fusarium infections in immunocompromised patients. Clin Microbiol Rev. 2007;20(4):695–704.
Summerell BA, Leslie JF, Liew ECY, Laurence MH, Bullock S, Petrovic T, Bentley AR, Howard CG, Peterson SA, Walsh JL, Burgess LW. Fusarium species associated with plants in Australia. Fungal Divers. 2011;46:1–27.
Brown NA, Hammond-Kosack KE. Secreted biomolecules in fungal plant pathogenesis. In: Gupta VK, Mach RL, Sreenivasaprasad S, editors. Fungal biomolecules: sources, applications and recent developments. Oxford: Wiley; 2015. p. 263–310.
Cuzick A, Urban M, Hammond-Kosack K. Fusarium graminearum gene deletion mutants map1 and tri5 reveal similarities and differences in the pathogenicity requirements to cause disease on Arabidopsis and wheat floral tissue. New Phytol. 2008;177(4):990–1000.
Oide S, Moeder W, Krasnoff S, Gibson D, Haas H, Yoshioka K, Turgeon BG. NPS6, encoding a nonribosomal peptide synthetase involved in siderophore-mediated iron metabolism, is a conserved virulence determinant of plant pathogenic ascomycetes. Plant Cell. 2006;18(10):2836–53.
Bluemke A, Falter C, Herrfurth C, Sode B, Bode R, Schaefer W, Feussner I, Voigt CA. Secreted fungal effector lipase releases free fatty acids to inhibit innate immunity-related callose formation during wheat head infection. Plant Physiol. 2014;165(1):346–58.
Brown NA, Urban M, Van De Meene AML, Hammond-Kosack KE. The infection biology of Fusarium graminearum: defining the pathways of spikelet to spikelet colonisation in wheat ears. Fungal Biol. 2010;114(7):555–71.
Brown NA, Bass C, Baldwin TK, Chen H, Massot F, Carion PWC, Urban M, van de Meene AML, Hammond-Kosack KE. Characterisation of the Fusarium graminearum-wheat floral interaction. J Pathogens. 2011;626345.
Brown NA, Antoniw J, Hammond-Kosack KE. The predicted secretome of the plant pathogenic fungus Fusarium graminearum: a refined comparative analysis. PLoS One. 2012;7(4):e33731.
Brewer HC, Hammond-Kosack KE. Host to a stranger: Arabidopsis and Fusarium ear blight. Trends Plant Sci. 2015;20(10):651–63.
O'Donnell K, Cigelnik E, Casper HH. Molecular phylogenetic, morphological, and mycotoxin data support reidentification of the Quorn mycoprotein fungus as Fusarium venenatum. Fungal Genet Biol. 1998;23(1):57–67.
Trinci APJ. Myco-protein: a twenty-year overnight success story. Mycol Res. 1992;96(1):1–13.
Trinci APJ. Evolution of the Quorn® myco-protein fungus, Fusarium graminearum A3/5. Microbiology. 1994;140:2181–8.
Trinci APJ, Robson GD, Wiebe MG. Evolution of Fusarium venenatum A3/5 in continuous flow (chemostat) culture. In: Fusarium: Paul E. Nelson Memorial Symposium; 2001. p. 161–75.
Royer JC, Moyer DL, Reiwitch SG, Madden MS, Jensen EB, Brown SH, Yonker CC, Johnstone JA, Golightly EJ, Yoder WT, et al. Fusarium graminearum A a 3/5 as a novel host for heterologous protein production. Biotechnology (N Y). 1995;13(13):1479–83.
Berka RM, Nelson BA, Zaretsky EJ, Yoder WT, Rey MW. Genomics of Fusarium venenatum: an alternative fungal host for making enzymes. In: Arora DK, Khachatourians GG, editors. Applied Mycology & Biotechnology, fungal genomics. Amsterdam: Elsevier Science; 2003.
Berka RM, Rey MW, Brown KM, Byun T, Klotz AV. Molecular characterization and expression of a phytase gene from the thermophilic fungus Thermomyces lanuginosus. Appl Environ Microbiol. 1998;64(11):4423–7.
Wiebe MG, Robson GD, Shuster JR, Trinci APJ. pH regulation of recombinant glucoamylase production in Fusarium venenatum JeRS 325, a transformant with a Fusarium oxysporum alkaline (trypsin-like) protease promoter. Biotechnology and Bioengineering. 1999;64(3):368–372.
Cuomo CA, Gueldener U, Xu J-R, Trail F, Turgeon BG, Di Pietro A, Walton JD, Ma L-J, Baker SE, Rep M, et al. The Fusarium graminearum genome reveals a link between localized polymorphism and pathogen specialization. Science. 2007;317(5843):1400–2.
Ma L-J, van der Does HC, Borkovich KA, Coleman JJ, Daboussi M-J, Di Pietro A, Dufresne M, Freitag M, Grabherr M, Henrissat B, et al. Comparative genomics reveals mobile pathogenicity chromosomes in Fusarium. Nature. 2010;464(7287):367–73.
King R, Urban M, Hammond-Kosack MCU, Hassani-Pak K, Hammond-Kosack KE. The completed genome sequence of the pathogenic ascomycete fungus Fusarium graminearum. BMC Genomics. 2015; https://doi.org/10.1186/s12864-015-1756-1.
Vanheule A, Audenaert K, Warris S, van de Geest H, Schijlen E, Hofte M, De Saeger S, Haesaert G, Waalwijk C, van der Lee T. Living apart together: crosstalk between the core and supernumerary genomes in a fungal plant pathogen. BMC Genomics. 2016; https://doi.org/10.1186/s12864-016-2941-6.
Urban M, Cuzick A, Rutherford K, Irvine A, Pedro H, Pant R, Sadanadan V, Khamari L, Billal S, Mohanty S, et al. PHI-base: a new interface and further additions for the multi-species pathogen-host interactions database. Nucleic Acids Res. 2017;45(D1):D604–10.
Pathogen Host Interactions (PHI-base). Rothamsted Research, Harpenden. 2017. http://www.phi-base.org. Accessed 21 Sept 2017.
McCallum BD, Tekauz A, Gilbert J. Barrage zone formation between vegetatively incompatible Fusarium graminearum (Gibberella zeae) isolates. Phytopathology. 2004;94(5):432–7.
Holt C, Yandell M. MAKER2: an annotation pipeline and genome-database management tool for second-generation genome projects. BMC Bioinf. 2011; https://doi.org/10.1186/1471-2105-12-491.
O'Donnell K, Rooney AP, Proctor RH, Brown DW, McCormick SP, Ward TJ, Frandsen RJN, Lysoe E, Rehner SA, Aoki T, et al. Phylogenetic analyses of RPB1 and RPB2 support a middle cretaceous origin for a clade comprising all agriculturally and medically important Fusaria. Fungal Genet Biol. 2013;52:20–31.
Ward TJ, Bielawski JP, Kistler HC, Sullivan E, O'Donnell K. Ancestral polymorphism and adaptive evolution in the trichothecene mycotoxin gene cluster of phytopathogenic Fusarium. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2002;99(14):9278–83.
Sieber CMK, Lee W, Wong P, Muensterkoetter M, Mewes H-W, Schmeitzl C, Varga E, Berthiller F, Adam G, Gueldener U. The Fusarium graminearum genome reveals more secondary metabolite gene clusters and hints of horizontal gene transfer. PLoS One. 2014; https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0110311.
Freitag M, Williams RL, Kothe GO, Selker EU. A cytosine methyltransferase homologue is essential for repeat-induced point mutation in Neurospora crassa. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2002;99(13):8802–7.
Galagan JE, Calvo SE, Borkovich KA, Selker EU, Read ND, Jaffe D, FitzHugh W, Ma LJ, Smirnov S, Purcell S, et al. The genome sequence of the filamentous fungus Neurospora crassa. Nature. 2003;422(6934):859–68.
Leslie JF, Summerell BA. The Fusarium laboratory manual. 1st ed. Ames: Blackwell Publishing Ltd; 2006.
Zhang Y, Zhang K, Fang A, Han Y, Yang J, Xue M, Bao J, Hu D, Zhou B, Sun X, et al. Specific adaptation of Ustilaginoidea virens in occupying host florets revealed by comparative and functional genomics. Nat Commun. 2014; https://doi.org/10.1038/ncomms4849.
Kimura M, Tokai T, Takahashi-Ando N, Ohsato S, Fujimura M. Molecular and genetic studies of Fusarium trichothecene biosynthesis: pathways, genes, and evolution. Biosci Biotechnol Biochem. 2007;71(9):2105–23.
Nasmith CG, Walkowiak S, Wang L, Leung WW, Gong Y, Johnston A, Harris LJ, Guttman DS, Subramaniam R. Tri6 is a global transcription regulator in the phytopathogen Fusarium graminearum. PLoS Pathog. 2011; https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.ppat.1002266.
Brown NA, Ries LNA, Goldman GH. How nutritional status signalling coordinates metabolism and lignocellulolytic enzyme secretion. Fungal Genetics and Biology. 2014;72:48-63.
Sperschneider J, Gardiner DM, Dodds PN, Tini F, Covarelli L, Singh KB, Manners JM, Taylor JM. EffectorP: predicting fungal effector proteins from secretomes using machine learning. New Phytol. 2016;210(2):743–61.
King R, Urban M, Hammond-Kosack KE. Annotation of Fusarium graminearum (PH-1) version 5.0. Genome Announc. 2017; https://doi.org/10.1128/genomeA.01479-16.
Sperschneider J, Gardiner DM, Thatcher LF, Lyons R, Singh KB, Manners JM, Taylor JM. Genome-wide analysis in three Fusarium pathogens identifies rapidly evolving chromosomes and genes associated with pathogenicity. Genome Biol Evol. 2015;7(6):1613–27.
Brown NA, Evans J, Mead A, Hammond-Kosack KE. A spatial temporal analysis of the Fusarium graminearum transcriptome during symptomless and symptomatic wheat infection. Mol Plant Pathol. 2017;18(9):1295–312.
Urban M, Pant R, Raghunath A, Irvine AG, Pedro H, Hammond-Kosack KE. The pathogen-host interactions database (PHI-base): additions and future developments. Nucleic Acids Res. 2015;43(D1):D645–55.
Brown NA, Urban M, Hammond-Kosack KE. The trans-kingdom identification of negative regulators of pathogen hypervirulence. FEMS Microbiol Rev. 2016;40(1):19–40.
Son H, Seo YS, Min K, Park AR, Lee J, Jin JM, Lin Y, Cao PJ, Hong SY, Kim EK, et al. A phenome-based functional analysis of transcription factors in the cereal head blight fungus, Fusarium graminearum. PLoS Pathog. 2011; https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.ppat.1002310.
Weber T, Blin K, Duddela S, Krug D, Kim HU, Bruccoleri R, Lee SY, Fischbach MA, Mueller R, Wohlleben W, et al. antiSMASH 3.0-a comprehensive resource for the genome mining of biosynthetic gene clusters. Nucleic Acids Res. 2015;43(W1):W237–43.
Khaldi N, Seifuddin FT, Turner G, Haft D, Nierman WC, Wolfe KH, Fedorova ND. SMURF: genomic mapping of fungal secondary metabolite clusters. Fungal Genet Biol. 2010;47(9):736–41.
Gueldener U, Seong K-Y, Boddu J, Cho S, Trail F, Xu J-R, Adam G, Mewes H-W, Muehlbauer GJ, Kistler HC. Development of a Fusarium graminearum Affymetrix GeneChip for profiling fungal gene expression in vitro and in planta. Fungal Genet Biol. 2006;43(5):316–25.
Dash S, Van Hemert J, Hong L, Wise RP, Dickerson JA. PLEXdb: gene expression resources for plants and plant pathogens. Nucleic Acids Res. 2012;40(Database issue):D1194–201.
Zhang XW, Jia LJ, Zhang Y, Jiang G, Li X, Zhang D, Tang WH. In planta stage-specific fungal gene profiling elucidates the molecular strategies of Fusarium graminearum growing inside wheat coleoptiles. Plant Cell. 2012;24(12):5159–76.
Gardiner DM, McDonald MC, Covarelli L, Solomon PS, Rusu AG, Marshall M, Kazan K, Chakraborty S, McDonald BA, Manners JM. Comparative pathogenomics reveals horizontally acquired novel virulence genes in fungi infecting cereal hosts. PLoS Pathog. 2012;8(9):e1002952. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.ppat.1002952
Diamond M, Reape TJ, Rocha O, Doyle SM, Kacprzyk J, Doohan FM, McCabe PF. The Fusarium mycotoxin deoxynivalenol can inhibit plant apoptosis-like programmed cell death. PLoS One. 2013; https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0069542.
Desmond OJ, Manners JM, Stephens AE, MaClean DJ, Schenk PM, Gardiner DM, Munn AL, Kazan K. The Fusarium mycotoxin deoxynivalenol elicits hydrogen peroxide production, programmed cell death and defence responses in wheat. Mol Plant Pathol. 2008;9(4):435–45.
McCluskey K, Wiest A, Plamann M. The Fungal Genetics Stock Center: a repository for 50 years of fungal genetics research. J Biosci. 2010;35(1):119-26.
Urban M, Mott E, Farley T, Hammond-Kosack K. The Fusarium graminearum MAP1 gene is essential for pathogenicity and development of perithecia. Mol Plant Pathol. 2003;4(5):347–59.
Zadoks JC, Chang TT, Konzak CF. A decimal code for the growth stages of cereals. Weed Res. 1974;14:415–21.
Doyle J, Doyle J. A rapid DNA isolation procedure for small quantities of fresh leaf tissue. Phytochem Bull. 1987;19:11–5.
Bentley DR, Balasubramanian S, Swerdlow HP, Smith GP, Milton J, Brown CG, Hall KP, Evers DJ, Barnes CL, Bignell HR, et al. Accurate whole human genome sequencing using reversible terminator chemistry. Nature. 2008;456(7218):53–9.
Kearse M, Moir R, Wilson A, Stones-Havas S, Cheung M, Sturrock S, Buxton S, Cooper A, Markowitz S, Duran C, et al. Geneious basic: an integrated and extendable desktop software platform for the organization and analysis of sequence data. Bioinformatics. 2012;28(12):1647–9.
Tempel S. Using and understanding RepeatMasker. Methods Mol Biol. 2012;859:29–51.
Solovyev V, Kosarev P, Seledsov I, Vorobyev D. Automatic annotation of eukaryotic genes, pseudogenes and promoters. Genome Biol. 2006;7(Suppl 1):S10.11–2.
Stanke M, Schoffmann O, Morgenstern B, Waack S. Gene prediction in eukaryotes with a generalized hidden Markov model that uses hints from external sources. BMC Bioinf. 2006; https://doi.org/10.1186/1471-2105-7-62.
Lukashin AV, Borodovsky M. GeneMark.hmm: new solutions for gene finding. Nucleic Acids Res. 1998;26(4):1107–15.
Korf I. Gene finding in novel genomes. BMC Bioinf. 2004;5:59.
Soanes DM, Skinner W, Keon J, Hargreaves J, Talbot NJ. Genomics of phytopathogenic fungi and the development of bioinformatic resources. Mol Plant Microbe Interact. 2002;15(5):421–7.
Lowe TM, Eddy SR. tRNAscan-SE. A program for improved detection of transfer RNA genes in genomic sequence. Nucleic Acids Res. 1997;25(5):955–64.
Nawrocki EP, Eddy SR. Infernal 1.1: 100-fold faster RNA homology searches. Bioinformatics. 2013;29(22):2933–5.
Li L, Stoeckert CJ Jr, Roos DS. OrthoMCL: identification of ortholog groups for eukaryotic genomes. Genome Res. 2003;13(9):2178–89.
Simao FA, Waterhouse RM, Ioannidis P, Kriventseva EV, Zdobnov EM. BUSCO: assessing genome assembly and annotation completeness with single-copy orthologs. Bioinformatics. 2015;31(19):3210–2.
Horton P, Park KJ, Obayashi T, Fujita N, Harada H, Adams-Collier CJ, Nakai K. WoLF PSORT: protein localization predictor. Nucleic Acids Res. 2007;35(Web Server issue):W585–7.
Eisenhaber B, Wildpaner M, Schultz CJ, Borner GH, Dupree P, Eisenhaber F. Glycosylphosphatidylinositol lipid anchoring of plant proteins. Sensitive prediction from sequence- and genome-wide studies for Arabidopsis and rice. Plant Physiol. 2003;133(4):1691–701.
Rice P, Longden I, Bleasby A. EMBOSS: the European molecular biology open software suite. Trends Genet. 2000;16(6):276–7.
Katoh K, Misawa K, Kuma K, Miyata T. MAFFT: a novel method for rapid multiple sequence alignment based on fast Fourier transform. Nucleic Acids Res. 2002;30(14):3059–66.
Stamatakis A, Hoover P, Rougemont J. A rapid bootstrap algorithm for the RAxML web servers. Syst Biol. 2008;57(5):758–71.
This work is supported by 20:20 Wheat® (BB/J00426X/1) and Designing Future Wheat (BBS/E/C/000I0250) strategic programmes funded by the Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council. The design of the study, collection, and some analysis of data was performed during 20:20 Wheat®, and the analysis, and interpretation during Designing Future Wheat. PHI-base receives support from the BBSRC as a National Capability (BB/J/004383/1) and the PhytoPath1 and PhytoPath2 projects (BB/1000488/1 and BB/K020056/1). Neil Brown was also supported by the BBSRC Future Leader Fellowship (BB/N011686/1).
Availability of data and materials
Sequence data that support the findings of this study have been deposited in the European Nucleotide Archive under the primary project accession code PRJEB7533. The phylogenetic tree has been desposited in treebase using accession code: S22361. All data generated or analysed during this study are included in this published article and its additional files.
Ethics approval and consent to participate
All experiments involving F. venenatum and non-UK Fusarium isolates were done in biological containment facilities under FERA licence number 101948/11982851/2.
Consent for publication
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Biological growth characteristics of F. venenatum compared to its close pathogenic relative F. graminearum. (A) Appearance of inoculated wheat head of cv. Bobwhite, 21 days after plug inoculations (dpi) with F. venenatum (Fv), (B) mock inoculation with water, (C) with F. graminearum (Fg). The white arrow indicates the inoculation points. (D) Appearance of wheat head 16 days after spray inoculation (dsi) with Fv, (E) mock spray inoculation with water, (F) spray inoculation with Fg. (G) Wheat seeds collected from a typical spray inoculated wheat head at 21 dsi with Fv, (H) mock spray with water, (I) with Fg. (J) Fv macrospores, (K) Fg macrospores. (L) Fv and (M) Fg growth on PDB plate at 6 days. (N) Fv inoculated tomato fruit at 4 days, (O) water control, (P) Fg. (Q) Fv inoculated tomato fruit at 12 days, (R) water control, (S) Fg. Bars in J, K: 10 μm. (PDF 268 kb)
Co-inoculation of F. venenatum with plant-pathogenic Fusaria in vitro and in vivo. (A) Carrot agar plate inoculated with agar plugs of strains Fv A3/5, two isolates of Fg (PH1 and 602), and Fc UK99. A barrage line between strains is visible at day 6. (B) F. culmorum and F. venenatum spores where mixed in equal amounts and co-inoculated into two spikelets at anthesis. As a control, water was inoculated (C) F. venenatum spores were sprayed onto wheat heads at the booting stage to potentially prime plant defence responses, followed by point-inoculation with F. culmorum spores of two heads per spike" should be "two spikelets per head at anthesis. (D) Wheat plants were treated as in C. Just after inoculaton with F. culmorum, wheat heads were sprayed once more with F. venenatum spores until run-off. Error bars show standard deviation, n = 6. (PDF 111 kb)
BUSCO analysis of proteomes for selected Fusaria. (XLS 1371 kb)
A phylogenetic tree of 904 identified common proteins (see Additional file 3) using F. solani, F. oxysporum, F. verticillioides, F. mangiferae, F. fujikuroi, F. proliferatum, F. poae, F. venenatum, F. langsethiae, F. graminearum and F. pseudograminearum. The substitution rate is on each branch and 100% branch support was found from 100 bootstraps. Type A, B, or A/B trichothecene producers were labelled. The tree was rooted to F. solani. (PDF 104 kb)
Comparative genomic analysis of the Fusarium venenatum genome with other fungi. This reveals close similarity to the pathogenic species F. graminearum and F. pseudograminearum. (XLS 37 kb)
Positions and lengths of Fusarium venenatum and Fusarium graminearum centromeres. This shows a 25% decrease in average size of the F. venenatum centromeres compared to Fusarium graminearum. (XLS 43 kb)
Comparison of the reference F. venenatum and F. graminearum genome sequences per individual chromosome (Chr) or supercontig (FV_1_1). Detailed comparisons of bp length and ‘N’ base content. (XLS 36 kb)
Comparative statistics on the number of coding and non-coding gene models predicted in the Fusarium venenatum (Fv) and F. graminearum (Fg) genomes. (XLS 29 kb)
Fusarium graminearum alignment and gene ID’s found in the inverted/translocated regions A/B/C in relation to Fusarium venenatum. Mauve alignments in Sheet 1 of Fusarium venenatum and F. graminearum chromosome 3. The small blue inversion/translocation in Fusarium graminearum has 56 genes, the small green translocation 144 genes, and the large blue/pink inversion/translocation has 586 genes (see Sheet 2–4). Below the top mauve alignment are F. venenatum and F. poae chromosome 3 aligned to F. graminearum using Lastz. (XLS 678 kb)
Classes of transposon and repeat found in Fusarium graminearum and Fusarium venenatum. (XLS 37 kb)
The mating locus within the F. venenatum and F. graminearum genomes. F. venenatum A3/5 contains only the MAT1–1 locus confirming heterothallism and the requirement for a complementary sexual partner. Whilst homothallic F. graminearum possesses both the MAT1–1 and MAT1–2 loci and hence does not require a complementary partner for sexual reproduction. Gene designations: A) FGRRES_08887, B) FGRRES_08888_M, C) FGRRES_08889_M, D) FGRRES_08894, E) FVRRES_05564, F) FGRRES_15525, G) FGRRES_13273_M. (PDF 90 kb)
Fusarium venenatum species-specific genes. An analysis of genes that lack a BLASTP top hit from NCBI nr database using 10− 6 and 10− 20 E-value cutoffs. (XLS 3165 kb)
A figure locating the positions of Fusarium venenatum species-specific genes versus NCBI, in relation to sequences predicted to be the secretome, tRNA, and transposons. (PDF 144 kb)
Species-specific proteins between F. venenatum (Fv) and F. graminearum (Fg), identified using BLASTP analysis of both Fv and Fg proteomes. (XLS 4938 kb)
Paralogue protein groups in Fusarium venenatum. Some groups show adjacent (neighbour) groupings representing recent duplications, whilst others represent near neighbours (< 40 genes) and others more distant duplications (> 100 genes). (XLS 38 kb)
A summary of secondary metabolite clusters (SMCs) found in Fusarium venenatum and F. graminearum. Using Sieber et al.  67 predictions as a template, SMURF and ANTISMASH were used to refine SMC predictions to 69 Fg SMCs and an additional 6 for Fv, combined with BLASTP of respective proteomes to identify presence in each species. (XLS 2940 kb)
Fusarium venenatum presence of TRI6 Fusarium greaminearum binding sites predicted by Nasmith et al. . Fusarium venenatum BLASTP alignment percentages were added to identify presence or absence. (XLS 61 kb)
Fusarium graminearum and F. venenatum secretome predictions and respective presence. (XLS 479 kb)
Annotation of Fusarium venenatum and Fusarium graminearum secretomes (A) reveals striking similar functional profiles. The enzymatic repertoire of F. venenatum and F. graminearum including secreted enzymes (B) and species-specific secreted enzymes (C). (TIFF 83 kb)
BLASTP analysis of previously identified pathogenicity factors. (XLS 37 kb)
BLASTP analysis of both Fusarium venenatum and F. graminearum proteomes against PHI-base v4.3. (XLS 2317 kb)
Fusarium graminearum specific genes and clusters and their expression during in vitro culture or during wheat head infection. (XLS 185 kb)
About this article
Cite this article
King, R., Brown, N.A., Urban, M. et al. Inter-genome comparison of the Quorn fungus Fusarium venenatum and the closely related plant infecting pathogen Fusarium graminearum. BMC Genomics 19, 269 (2018) doi:10.1186/s12864-018-4612-2
- Fusarium graminearum
- Fusarium venenatum
- Comparative genome analyses
- Secondary metabolite clusters
- PHI-base genes
- Species-specific genes